Gendered pathways to adolescent mental health: An empirical assessment of a new conceptual framework.
PLOS global public health · 2026
Abstract originale
Gender norms and roles are important determinants of physical and mental health in the key period of adolescence. Yet, the gendered pathways to mental health in adolescents are not fully understood. Using a conceptual framework for global adolescent mental health that we developed based on a Delphi process, we empirically investigated the associations between six gender-related constructs and adolescent mental health. We used an existing cross-sectional dataset from Ethiopia (2020) from the Gender and Adolescence: Global Evidence (GAGE) project to explore the associations between sex, gender norms, psychological competencies, gender attitudes, gender roles, with the latter two also serving as mediators, and psychological distress (GHQ-12), using Structural Equation Modelling (SEM). The SEM model contained measurements from 1,651 adolescents, including 901 girls and 750 boys, with a median age of 13 years. Out of 14 pathways tested, we found statistically significant associations between psychological competencies and psychological distress; sex and psychological distress; sex and gender attitudes; and between gender norms and psychological competencies, gender attitudes, and gender roles. Hence, the gender-related constructs were mostly associated with each other, rather than with psychological distress. The gender-related constructs were associated with each other rather than with psychological distress. The mechanisms underlying these relationships and a potential interplay of gender-related pathways require longitudinal investigation.
Leggi il testo integrale originale
Testo estratto dalla pubblicazione: sono esclusi immagini, media, supplementi e parti soggette a diritti distinti.
Gendered pathways to adolescent mental health: An empirical assessment of a new conceptual framework Empirical assessment of a new conceptual framework
Gender norms and roles are important determinants of physical and mental health in the key period of adolescence. Yet, the gendered pathways to mental health in adolescents are not fully understood. Using a conceptual framework for global adolescent mental health that we developed based on a Delphi process, we empirically investigated the associations between six gender-related constructs and adolescent mental health. We used an existing cross-sectional dataset from Ethiopia (2020) from the Gender and Adolescence: Global Evidence (GAGE) project to explore the associations between sex, gender norms, psychological competencies, gender attitudes, gender roles, with the latter two also serving as mediators, and psychological distress (GHQ-12), using Structural Equation Modelling (SEM). The SEM model contained measurements from 1,651 adolescents, including 901 girls and 750 boys, with a median age of 13 years. Out of 14 pathways tested, we found statistically significant associations between psychological competencies and psychological distress; sex and psychological distress; sex and gender attitudes; and between gender norms and psychological competencies, gender attitudes, and gender roles. Hence, the gender-related constructs were mostly associated with each other, rather than with psychological distress. The gender-related constructs were associated with each other rather than with psychological distress. The mechanisms underlying these relationships and a potential interplay of gender-related pathways require longitudinal investigation.
1. Introduction
Adolescence is the first stage of life in which sex differences in mental health emerge in terms of morbidity and mortality [1]. Mental health problems, such as depression, anxiety and suicidality, increase sharply during this period [2]. This phenomenon and the magnitude of these problems have been reported globally [3]. These sex differences are assumed to, at least in part, stem from gender norms, roles, and relations [4]. However, it is not yet known through which specific pathways or mechanisms gender affects mental health outcomes in adolescents [1,5].
Gender norms, roles, and relations are acquired through gender socialisation, defined as the “process by which individuals learn the cultural behaviours associated with the concepts of femininity or masculinity” [6]. This process begins primarily in the family as parents directly or indirectly influence children to conform to expected gender norms, roles and relations [7]. The effects of gender socialisation become particularly evident during adolescence [8].
The school environment can reinforce the gender socialisation process through teachers (e.g., gendered role assignments) and peers (e.g., bullying due to gender non-conformity) [9]. Gender norms either incentivise or disincentivise specific health behaviours, potentially leading to adverse (mental) health outcomes [10]. “Beliefs about appropriate roles for males and females regarding the division of paid labor, homework, and childcare” [11] are often referred to as gender role attitudes, although great variability in the conceptualisation of gender roles exists. Masculine gender role characteristics are a protective factor against depression and depressive symptoms [4]. The use of social media can be associated with increased mental distress [12]. Media and social media use play an important role in reproducing social pressures and increase the exposure to stereotyping, objectifying and sexualising representations, which in turn strengthen beliefs in, e.g., gender stereotypes and body ideals [13]. Psychological competencies, such as coping skills, have been identified as strong determinants of well-being not only in individuals with mental health disorders but also in the absence of mental disorders [14].
To explore more complex gendered pathways to adolescent mental health, we previously developed a conceptual framework (hereafter referred to as the ‘GAM framework’) in an international Delphi study [15]. It encompasses six gender-related constructs, namely sex assigned at birth, gender identity, gender norms (of the social environment), gender attitudes, gender roles, psychological competencies, and mental health. As gender norms, roles, and attitudes are often conflated conceptually, we define gender norms as the “spoken and unspoken rules of societies about the acceptable behaviours of girls and boys […] - how they should act, look, and even think or feel” [10], while we define gender attitudes as the individual perceptions toward these gender norms [9]. Gender roles concern the “sexual division of labor, where specific tasks are strictly assigned based on gender” [16]. The framework also incorporates a range of socio-demographic variables that together form an intersectional lens. The gender-related constructs are hypothesised to be associated with adolescent mental health but have not yet been empirically tested. Therefore, we investigate multiple (mediated) regression models via Structural Equation Modelling (SEM) for analysis of the interlinked effects. SEM is considered an innovative approach for analysing sex/gender [17], is compatible with an intersectional approach [18], and is used in cross-sectional studies [19]. We also conduct Exploratory (EFA) and Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) to validate a newly developed gender norms scale for the dataset employed in this study. The EFA serves to explore and refine the scale’s underlying factor structure, while the CFA aims to confirm the hypothesised factor model of the EFA in a confirmatory setting [20].
2. Materials and methods
2.1. Ethical approval
Our study did not require ethical approval, as it is based on the secondary analysis of previously collected, publicly available, fully anonymous, and non-identifiable third-party data.
2.2. Data
Our secondary data analysis draws on quantitative data from the Gender & Adolescence: Global Evidence (GAGE) project, a ten-year (2015–2024) mixed-methods longitudinal research and evaluation programme. GAGE surveys 18,000 adolescents aged 10–19 years and other community members across six countries in the Global South, with a particular focus on vulnerable adolescents, such as those with disabilities, who married before the age of 18, refugees, adolescent mothers and out-of-school youth [21]. We use cross-sectional data from the second round of data collection in Ethiopia in 2020, as it includes validated tools for mental health and gender-related variables. Data collection took place in six locations in Ethiopia. A household census was used to identify potential participants [22]. In addition to the random sample, out-of-school adolescents and adolescents with disabilities were purposefully collected by the GAGE project [21]. Sampling weights reflect the probability of selection into the study sample and ensure the representativeness of the target population in the study area. Further details on data collection procedures are described in Baird et al. [22]. The data on which the results of our study are based are third-party data that are publicly archived by the data provider ‘UK data service’ (https://ukdataservice.ac.uk/). They are available free of charge for any researcher following registration with the data provider. We have complied with the data provider’s terms of use.
2.3. Measures
We operationalised measures guided by the proposed operationalisations of the GAM framework [15]. Fig 1 is an adaptation of this framework based on the data available in the Ethiopian dataset.
We used the binary variable sex for the construct sex assigned at birth. We could not operationalise the construct of gender identity as no such measure exists in the dataset. While we could not operationalise the household and political levels of gender norms due to a lack of appropriate items, we operationalised the community level with a peer violence index and being a club member, and the digital level with having a role model, media, and social media use. We chose these operationalisations for the gender norms construct because the GAM framework operationalises this construct based on actors who carry gender norms that influence adolescents’ gender attitudes in different social environment levels, with the community level consisting of the indicators peers and school, and the digital level of media, social media, and influencers [15]. We recoded these variables so that higher values indicate higher exposure to gender norms. A detailed description of the recoded variables is shown in S1 Appendix.
We operationalised gender attitudes using the GAGE gender norms scale (although it is labelled as a gender norms scale, it measures adolescents’ perceptions of gender norms, that is, gender attitudes). In previous work [23], we explored the factor structure of this newly developed scale using data from an earlier GAGE round. The scale combines items from existing adolescent gender norms scales with items developed specifically for the GAGE project, but neither the original scales nor the GAGE scale have undergone prior empirical validation for the specific study population under investigation. Therefore, we explored its factor structure in the present sample. Following methodological recommendations and our previous approach, we used EFA, as the underlying factor structure could not be assumed a priori, and subsequently tested the hypothesised factor model of the EFA in a confirmatory setting using CFA (see S2 Appendix) [20]. Ultimately, the CFA suggested retaining 20 of the scale’s original 32 items as a latent variable with seven sum scores (hereafter referred to as gender attitudes subscale F1-F7). We recoded the scale so that a higher score indicates more gender egalitarian attitudes.
Gender roles can be defined by the sexual division of labour, where specific tasks are assigned based on gender and are operationalised in the GAM framework by time spent on gendered activities. Accordingly, we operationalised the gender roles construct with a gendered activities score. A higher score translates to more hours spent on activities per day, indicating adherence to more traditional gender roles.
We operationalised the construct psychological competencies with six instruments: a voice index; a resilience index; an index for talking to caregivers about work, religion, education, and bullying; speaking up in class; expression of opinion to friends; and to elders. These variables were recoded so that higher values indicate a higher level of psychological competencies.
We operationalised the mental health construct using the validated instrument General Health Questionnaire (GHQ)-12. The GHQ-12 is a short and self-administered screening tool to detect symptoms of psychological distress and short-term changes in mental health [24]. A higher GHQ-12 score translates to increased psychological distress.
2.4. Statistical analysis
2.4.1. Structural equation modelling.
We employed SEM to simultaneously explore the hypothesised associations between the gender-related construct and adolescent mental health using a mix of measured, observed variables and unmeasured, latent variables. SEM subsumes various other statistical techniques, including CFA, path analysis, and multiple regression analysis.
We tested for multivariate normality (Shapiro-Wilk normality test), multicollinearity (Variance Inflation Factor), and common method bias (Harman’s Single Factor Test). We then developed and tested the measurement model for the latent variables using CFA. We used the Chi-squared test statistics, the Bentler Comparative Fit Index (CFI), the Tucker-Lewis Index (TLI), the Goodness-of-Fit Index (GFI), the Adjusted Goodness-of-Fit Index (AGFI), the Root Mean Square Error of Approximation (RMSEA), and the Standard Root Mean Square Residual (SRMR) to assess model fit [20,25]. Thresholds for good model fits are: CFI, TLI, GFI, AGFI ≥ 0.90, RMSEA < 0.06, and SRMR < 0.08 [20,25]. We assessed localised areas of model misfit using standardised factor loadings with the commonly recommended threshold of 0.4 [26]. Due to factor loadings below 0.4, we removed the indicators social media, voice, expression of opinion to friends, expression of opinion to elders, the peer violence index, and the gender attitudes subscales F3, F5, F6, and F7. Removing these gender attitudes subscales results in a gender attitudes construct that is narrower than the validated 20-item scale. The remaining gender attitudes subscales F1, F2, and F4 in the SEM model cover 10 items from the content domains of education, violence, and time use.
We estimated parameters using maximum likelihood with robust standard errors to account for non-normality as indicated by the Shapiro-Wilk normality test. We applied sample weights to ensure representativeness of the Ethiopian adolescent population, and we treated ordinal variables with ≥5 response categories as continuous. Subsequently, we specified a structural model to assess the extent to which the exogenous and mediator variables explain the variance in the dependent variables psychological competencies and the outcome mental health. This resulted in five regression and four mediation models. We obtained the share of mediation as the quotient of the absolute indirect effect by the absolute total effect. Following the intersectional lens in the GAM framework, we included a range of covariates as predictors for the two exogenous variables gender norms and sex.
In addition, we conducted sensitivity analyses to test the robustness of the gender norms construct by i) removing both the club member and role model variables (Table A in S3 Appendix), ii) by removing only the club member variable (Table B in S3 Appendix), and iii) by removing only the role model variable (Table C in S3 Appendix). Statistical significance was assessed at the 5% level. We conducted all analyses in R version 4.5.2 (R Core Team, 2025). We estimated the CFA and SEM using the “lavaan” package version 0.6-21 [27], and followed reporting guidelines for SEM [28].
3. Results
3.1. Sample characteristics
Our sample included measures of 1,651 adolescents with complete data. The descriptive statistics are presented in Table 1. The sample comprised a higher number of girls (55%) than boys (45%), with an average age of 13 years (standard deviation (SD): 0.9). The average GHQ-12 score was 7.0 (SD: 3.8), which is below the validated GHQ-12 cut-off of 9 for boys and 10 for girls for psychological distress and a potential mental disorder [29]. The study participants reached a relatively high resilience score of 20 (SD: 4.0). The sample had slightly more equal than unequal gender attitudes with a value of 41 (SD: 6.7) and spent on average two hours per day on gendered activities (SD: 2.2). More adolescents expressed their opinions to their friends (78%) than to older people (45%). They talked on average about two of the four sensitive topics with their parents (SD: 2.3) and scored 19 on perceived influence in family matters. About half of the participants reported having a role model (54%) and being a member of a club (46%). 87% and 40% of adolescents reported not using social media and media, respectively, in the last 30 days. The peer violence index indicated low peer violence with 0.9 (SD: 1.8).
10.1371/journal.pgph.0006728.t001Table 1Descriptive statistics of the variables operationalising the GAM framework (n = 1,651).
Variable n (%)mean ± SD (range)
Outcome
Mental Health
GHQ-12 score 7.0 ± 3.8 (0-36)
Exposures of interest
Sex assigned at birth
Sex
Boys 750 (45.4)
Girls 901 (54.6)
Competencies
Resilience score 20.1 ± 4.0 (0-24)
Index for talking to parents about work, religion, education, and bullying 2.6 ± 1.2 (0-4)
Voice score 18.7 ± 5.1 (8-32)
Expression of opinion to friends
No 371 (22.5)
Yes 1279 (77.5)
Expression of opinion to elderly
No 917 (55.5)
Yes 734 (44.5)
Gender Attitudes
Gender attitudes subscale F1* 10.2 ± 2.2 (4–12)
Gender attitudes subscale F2* 6.3 ± 2.1 (3–9)
Gender attitudes subscale F3* 4.9 ± 1.5 (2–6)
Gender attitudes subscale F4* 5.3 ± 2.0 (3–9)
Gender attitudes subscale F5* 5.9 ± 1.9 (4–12)
Gender attitudes subscale F6* 3.2 ± 1.3 (2–6)
Gender attitudes subscale F7* 5.4 ± 1.0 (2–6)
Gender attitudes scale overall sum score (20 items of F1-F7) 41.3 ± 6.7 (20-58)
Gender Roles
Gendered Activities score 2.1 ± 2.3 (0-13)
Gender Norms
Having a role model
No 755 (45.7)
Yes 896 (54.3)
Being a club member
No 856 (54.0)
Yes 728 (46.0)
Social media use
Never 1424 (86.5)
Hardly ever 89 (5.4)
At least every week 94 (5.4)
Daily or almost daily 21 (1.3)
Several times a week 12 (0.7)
Almost all the time 7 (0.4)
Media use
Never 653 (39.6)
Hardly ever 212 (12.8)
At least every week 227 (13.8)
Daily or almost daily 279 (16.9)
Several times a week 190 (11.5)
Almost all the time 90 (5.5)
Peer violence index 0.9 ± 1.8 (0-12)
Covariates
Age 13.0 ± 0.9 (9–14)
Being married
No 1511 (95.4)
Yes 73 (4.6)
Urbanisation
Rural 1014 (61.4)
Urban 637 (38.6)
Purposefully sampled
No 1504 (91.1)
Yes 147 (8.9)
Disability
No 1532 (92.8)
Yes 119 (7.2)
Language in HH
Afan Oromo 429 (26.0)
Afar 263 (15.9)
Amharic 933 (56.5)
Somali 26 (1.6)
Asset index 6.1 ± 5.1 (0-48)**
Aspirations higher education
No aspirations 120 (7.3)
Secondary education 388 (23.5)
Teacher training 75 (4.5)
University education 1068 (64.7)
Working in family business
No 1582 (95.8)
Yes 69 (4.2)
Father in household
No 1200 (72.7)
Yes 451 (27.3)
*Reduced, validated set of gender attitudes items (2nd version based on 20 gender attitudes items with seven subscales due to seven identified factors, see S2 Appendix).
**Interpretation: Participants possess 6 items across 16 asset categories in their households: mattress and/or bed; working refrigerator or freezer; working computer, laptop, or tablet; working mobile phone; working non-mobile phone; working radio; working television; working bicycle; working motorcycle, motor scooter or bajaj; working car or truck; working wrist watch / clock; working solar panel; sofa set; table; chair; plow.
3.2. Structural equation modelling
The fully specified SEM model included data for 1,651 adolescents from 1,651 households. We found no multicollinearity, as all variance inflation factors (VIF) were below 1.7 (threshold <5) [30]. Additionally, no common method bias was detected, with a proportion of variance of 0.22 (threshold <0.5). The SEM model simultaneously fitted latent variables, multiple regression models, and multiple mediation paths (Fig 2). In sensitivity analyses, we also modelled residual covariances and additional regression paths between latent variables and covariates using modification indices.
The fit statistics of the SEM model presented a mixed picture: The RMSEA and the SRMR (≤0.06) indicated a good absolute model fit. The CFI, TLI, GFI and AGFI, with values of 0.82, 0.75, 0.91, and 0.80, respectively, fell mostly below the recommended ≥0.90 threshold. This indicates that the model does not adequately capture the data structure of the specified model. The Chi-Squared test, with χ²(155)=1041.886, p < 0.001, rejected the null hypothesis, indicating that the model does not fit the data. However, it is well known that the Chi-Squared test is sensitive to sample size and tends to reject the null hypothesis for sample sizes over 400 observations [20].
Six of ten analysed regression paths were statistically significant (Table 2). Psychological competencies were negatively associated with psychological distress, which means that a higher level of competencies was, on average, associated with lower values of psychological distress and thus better mental health. Being a girl (vs. being a boy) was also, on average, associated with lower psychological distress.
10.1371/journal.pgph.0006728.t002Table 2Results of the model fit, the latent variables, and the regression analysis in the SEM model (N = 1,651).
Model Fit Statistics
Fit Statistics Value
Chi-Squared 1041.886, p<0.001
Df 155
CFI 0.82
TLI 0.75
GFI 0.91
AGFI 0.80
RMSEA 0.059
SRMR 0.038
Confirmatory Factor Analysis
Latent Construct SFL FL (SE)
Competencies
Index talking to parents 0.59 1.0 (-)
Resilience Score 0.64 3.60 (0.28)
Gender Norms
Media use 0.59 1.0 (-)
Having a role model 0.41 0.22 (0.02)
Being a club member 0.44 0.24 (0.02)
Gender Attitudes
Gender Attitudes Subscale F1 0.60 1.0 (-)
Gender Attitudes Subscale F2 0.57 0.88 (0.06)
Gender Attitudes Subscale F4 0.61 0.87 (0.06)
Regression Analysis
Variable ß (SE) 95 % CI p-value
Outcome: Mental Health
Gender Attitudes -0.11 (0.18) [-0.46; 0.24] p=0.533
Sex
Ref.: Male
Female -0.49 (0.24) [-0.96; -0.02] p=0.040
Gender Roles -0.08 (0.07) [-0.21; 0.05] p=0.235
Gender Norms 0.30 (0.34) [-0.38; 0.98] p=0.377
Competencies -1.71 (0.42) [-2.53; -0.89] p<0.001
Outcome: Competencies
Gender Roles 0.02 (0.02) [-0.02; 0.05] p=0.387
Gender Norms 0.68 (0.08) [0.54; 0.83] p<0.001
Outcome: Gender Attitudes
Gender Norms 0.90 (0.09) [0.72; 1.07] p<0.001
Sex
Ref.: Male
Female 0.54 (0.09) [0.36; 0.72] p<0.001
Outcome: Gender Roles
Gender Norms -1.37 (0.08) [-1.53; -1.20] p<0.001
Ref. = Reference category; ß = beta coefficient, CI = Confidence interval, SFL = Standardised factor loading, FL = Factor loading, SE = Standard error, CFI = Bentler Comparative Fit Index, TLI = Tucker-Lewis Index, GFI = Goodness-of-Fit Index, AGFI = Adjusted Goodness-of-Fit Index, RMSEA = Root Mean Square Error of Approximation, SRMR = Standard Root Mean Square Residual, Df = Degrees of freedom
Bold text = p < 0.05
Competencies R2 = 65.2%; Gender norms R2 = 71.0%; Gender attitudes R2 = 62.5%; Psychological distress R2 = 7.7%; Gender roles R2 = 34.8%; Sex R2 = 8.7%
Note:
1) The regression analysis was performed simultaneously in one SEM model and was adjusted for: age, work (working in family business or not working in family business), aspiration for higher education (aspiration for secondary school, teacher training, university, or no such aspiration), disability (living with disability or without disability), language spoken in the household (vernacular Afan Oromo, Afar, Amharic or Somali), urbanisation (living in urban or rural area), father living in household (living or not living in household), asset index (sum score capturing material factors in the household), sampling mode (purposeful or non-purposeful), and marital status (married before age 18 or not), regressed on the two exogeneous variables
2) Residual covariances between: gender roles and sex, gender attitudes subscale F4 and psychological distress, gender attitudes subscale F4 and female sex, media and gender roles, resilience and gender attitudes subscale F2 based on the modification indices; regressions: language Afan Oromo predicting gender attitudes (ß:-0.78, SE: 0.11, CI[-1.00; -0.56], p < 0.001), urbanisation predicting competencies (ß: 0.31, SE: 0.06, CI[0.20; 0.43], p < 0.001), language Afar predicting gender attitudes (ß: -0.64, SE:0.15, CI[-0.93; -0.34], p < 0.001) based on the modification indices.
Higher exposure to gender norms and more hours spent on gendered activities were, on average, associated with higher levels of competence, albeit only significantly for gender norms. Being a girl compared to being a boy and being more exposed to gender norms were positively and significantly associated with more egalitarian gender attitudes. Higher exposure to gender norms was negatively associated with more egalitarian gender roles, which means that higher exposure to gender norms was, on average, associated with fewer hours spent on gendered activities.
Egalitarian gender attitudes and traditional gender roles were also negatively but not significantly associated with psychological distress. In contrast, higher exposure to gender norms was positively and not significantly associated with psychological distress.
The sensitivity analyses testing the robustness of the gender norms construct showed that the differences in model fit statistics between the initial model and the three sensitivity analyses were fairly minor, and the model with both variables (club member and role model) removed showed reduced model fit statistics (Tables A, B, and C in S3 Appendix). The estimates remain stable when the variable club membership or role model is removed individually. Tables B and C in S3 Appendix. When both variables are removed. (Table A in S3 Appendix), the media-only model no longer has a positive-definite covariance matrix for the residuals of the observed variables. This means that the matrix is singular and has at least one eigenvalue that is zero or negative, which could be attributed to the now single-indicator latent construct gender norms, with media as the only remaining variable in the latent construct. This model yields three different findings: sex is no longer significantly associated with psychological distress (p = 0.058), and gender roles becomes significantly associated both with psychological distress (p = 0.044) and competencies (p < 0.001). However, due to the model estimation error, the estimates in the media-only model cannot be considered reliable.
We found no statistically significant mediation effects (Table 3). All estimated indirect effects were negative, except for the pathway from gender norms to psychological distress through egalitarian gender roles. Notably, the indirect effects of higher exposure to gender norms on psychological distress differ, as the former is modelled through two pathways, egalitarian gender attitudes and traditional gender roles, neither of which reached significance. The ratios of the total indirect effect to the total effect were 10.8%, 31.5%, 34.5% and 3.3%, respectively. The second and fourth ratios in Table 3 may represent competitive mediations, indicating suppression effects (although non-significant).
10.1371/journal.pgph.0006728.t003Table 3Results of the mediation analysis in the SEM model (N = 1,651).
Variable Direct effect Indirect effect Total indirect effect Total effect Ratio mediation
Outcome: Psychological distress
ß-coefficient (mediator: gender attitudes):
Sex -0.49 [-0.96; 0.02], p = 0.040 -0.06 [-0.25; 0.13]p = 0.536 -0.06 [-0.25; 0.13]p = 0.536 -0.55 [-0.98; -0.13]p = 0.011 10.8%
Gender Norms 0.30 [-0.37; 0.98], p = 0.377 -0.10 [-0.41; 0.21]p = 0.536 0.01 [-0.35; 0.37]p = 0.959 0.31 [-0.20; 0.83]p = 0.234 31.5%N
ß-coefficient (mediator: gender roles):
Gender Norms 0.30 [-0.37; 0.98], p = 0.377 0.11 [-0.07; 0.29]p = 0.237 0.01 [-0.35; 0.37]p = 0.959 0.31 [-0.20; 0.83]p = 0.234 34.5%
Outcome: Competencies
ß-coefficient (mediator: gender roles)
Gender Norms 0.68 [0.54; 0.83], p < 0.001 -0.02 [-0.07; 0.03]p = 0.390 -0.02 [-0.07; 0.03]p = 0.390 0.66 [0.54; 0.78]p < 0.001 03.3%N
Square brackets = 95% Confidence Intervals
Bold text = p < 0.05
[] = 95% Confidence interval; p = p-value
All values are rounded to the second decimal number
N = negative ratio
4. Discussion
4.1. Principal findings
In this study, we empirically tested the hypothesised pathways from the GAM framework [15]. We employed SEM to simultaneously model the set of gender-related constructs and their relationships with mental health, including a wide range of covariates to operationalise the intersectional lens applied in the framework. Based on these data collected from Ethiopian adolescents, six of ten regression paths and none of four mediation paths were statistically significant. Since the SEM model does not provide an optimal representation of the data, the significant paths should be interpreted as an initial assessment of the plausibility of the proposed pathways.
In the regression models, higher exposure to gender norms was significantly associated with both fewer hours spent on gendered activities (gender roles construct) and more egalitarian gender attitudes. The former association between gender norms (operationalised by being a member of a club, having a role model, and media use) and gender roles might be explained by an increased use of media, which was found to be associated with physical inactivity [31]. Physical inactivity may also extend to household and caregiving activities. Being enrolled in a club may also contribute to less time spent in the household and, as a result, fewer household and caregiving activities. The association between higher exposure to gender norms and more egalitarian gender attitudes supports a contact hypothesis, arguing that stereotypes are lower when individuals regularly meet, such as in sports clubs [32].
Furthermore, higher exposure to gender norms was associated with higher levels of psychological competencies. Extracurricular activities have been linked to promoting social and emotional competencies in young people [33]. Interactions with other adolescents, such as in a club, could thus contribute to developing adolescents’ competencies and ultimately promote mental health.
Higher levels of psychological competencies were negatively associated with psychological distress, indicating better mental health. This finding is consistent with the literature that psychological competencies are an important determinant of well-being, even in individuals without mental disorders [14]. The negative directionality of the significant association between female sex (vs. male sex) and psychological distress is noteworthy, indicating that being an adolescent girl is associated with lower psychological distress and thus better mental health. While girls tend to have lower mental health than boys [22] in most countries, a possible explanation for this opposite directionality in this study could be that we controlled for multiple gender-related constructs that intersect at the individual and meta-level and without which the negative effects on girls could be reversed. Moreover, countries with higher gender inequities exhibit some of the smallest gender gaps in mental health. In some cases, this gap is reversed, with boys reporting worse mental health than girls [34]. Also, lower expectations of gender equity could result in fewer feelings of both unmet expectations and relative deprivation [35]. Nevertheless, the directionality identified in this study must be confirmed in future studies, which should also investigate hypotheses regarding potential underlying mechanisms using longitudinal study designs.
The observed association of egalitarian gender attitudes with psychological distress was not significant, but existing literature would similarly indicate an association between egalitarian gender attitudes and (better) mental health [12,14,36]. The association of traditional gender roles with psychological distress was also non-significant, but is equally noteworthy as the association between sex and psychological distress, as it would suggest that traditional gender roles (i.e., more hours spent on gendered activities) could reduce psychological distress (although non-significant). Findings from countries similar to Ethiopia indicate that adherence to gender roles within a predominantly gendered normative context may contribute to better mental health, as gender roles might be more clearly defined, potentially resulting in less role conflict and a reduced double burden [34]. However, the non-significant finding and cross-sectional study design do not support this hypothesis.
We could not find evidence for mediation effects in our SEM model. The direct effect between higher exposure to gender norms and psychological distress had a positive directionality, while more egalitarian gender attitudes showed a negative, non-significant indirect effect. The same directionality is evident in the relationship between gender norms and competencies through gender roles. These positive direct and negative indirect effects may partly cancel each other out and produce a much smaller coefficient total effect. Although exploratory and non-significant, this may reflect the complex interplay between the gender-related constructs.
Consequently, the gender-related pathways analysed in the SEM model appear to be more strongly associated with each other than directly associated with mental health. This is also reflected in the low R2 of the primary outcome of psychological distress, which indicates that our model only explains 7.7% of the variation in mental health. Besides the fact that we controlled for gender-related constructs, another possible explanation may be the overall relatively high self-perceived mental health status of the Ethiopian adolescents. This could have limited the variability in the outcome measure and reduced the ability to detect subtle differences. Moreover, in countries with higher gender inequity, sex differences in mental health tend to be smaller. Traditional gendered expectations may be perceived as normative rather than oppressive [34], thereby mitigating their direct effect on psychological distress. Psychological competencies might be a more proximal factor for psychological distress than the other gender-related constructs and might therefore impact mental health more immediately. In this SEM model, we focused on gender-related pathways to adolescent mental health and thus may have left out other influential predictors for psychological distress.
4.2. Strengths and limitations
SEM is an innovative yet still underutilised statistical method for analysing sex/gender in social epidemiology [17,37]. It can be employed to simultaneously investigate potential relationships across multiple variables [17], which is compatible with an intersectional approach [18]. We followed reporting guidelines [28] and statistical recommendations for SEM and mediation analysis (e.g., large sample size, the ratio of mediations) [38]. We studied indirect and complex relationships through latent variables, which allowed us to model measurement error, as well as multiple regression and mediations [39]. Moreover, we used EFA and CFA to ensure the appropriateness of the GAGE gender attitudes scale for the study population. The findings are representative of GAGE’s target population in the study area, but may also be relevant for a similar adolescent population in countries with comparable cultural contexts.
Limitations arise from the GAGE dataset and from our analytical approach. First, we could not examine gender identity due to its absence in the dataset. This is important, as transgender and gender non-conforming adolescents often experience greater discrimination and more pronounced adverse mental health outcomes than their cisgender peers [40]. Second, despite being collected by trained interviewers, the data may be subject to social desirability bias. Third, many measures reflect perceived rather than objective measures. To mitigate this limitation, we prioritised measures that were as objective as possible. For example, gender roles were operationalised using time spent on gendered activities rather than attitudes towards gender roles, which are conceptually difficult to distinguish from other gender attitudes. Fourth, we operationalised the gender norms construct in accordance with propositions from the GAM framework. However, the indicators measure a potential exposure to gender norms rather than gender norms specifically. This may introduce measurement bias and limit construct validity.
Limitations also relate to our analytical approach. While absolute fit indices such as RMSEA and SRMR suggest a small misfit per degree of freedom and small standardised discrepancies between the observed and model-implied correlations, relative fit indices such as CFI and TLI fell below recommended thresholds, indicating that the specified model might not fully capture the underlying data structure. Several factors may contribute to this, including model complexity, large sample size, numerous covariates necessary to operationalise the intersectional lens, local model misspecifications, and the use of sample weights [39]. We investigated modification indices to identify potential sources of misfit. We incorporated residual covariances and regressions between latent variables and covariates (so as not to change the structural model) into our SEM model. We did not include any further indicators in the latent variables, as this would alter the interpretation of the constructs and thus result in an SEM model that no longer corresponds to the GAM framework. Since model evaluation should be guided by both theory and statistical fit [39], we assessed model fit by combining theoretical considerations with fit statistics. Although the remaining modification indices do not show a clear pattern suitable for any interpretations regarding other sources of misfit, a substantial unexplained misfit remains. The SEM model does not provide an optimal representation of the data but can be interpreted as an initial assessment of the plausibility of the proposed pathways. Future research should examine the proposed relationships using alternative model specifications that are not constrained by the GAM framework and adapt the framework accordingly.
Given the complexity of our SEM model, we used cross-sectional data as a first step of theory and plausibility testing. As is common in cross-sectional data, they limit the causal ordering assumption. Future research should seek to use longitudinal data to assess the causality and directionality of the effects.
4.3. Conclusions
We found significant associations between psychological competencies and psychological distress; sex and psychological distress; sex and gender attitudes; and between gender norms and psychological competencies, gender attitudes, and gender roles among Ethiopian adolescents. Therefore, the gender-related constructs were associated with each other rather than with psychological distress. The mechanisms underlying these relationships and a potential interplay of gender-related pathways should be further investigated using longitudinal study designs that can establish causality and better investigate dose-response relationships.
Supporting information
References
1Dil L , Mérelle S , Lommerse N , Peen J , So P , Van R , et al. Gender-specific pathways in mental health crisis in adolescents, from consultation to (in)voluntary admission: a retrospective study . BMC Psychiatry . 2024 ;24 (1 ):235 . doi: 10.1186/s12888-024-05680-9 38549065 PMC10976791
2Thomson KC , Romaniuk H , Greenwood CJ , Letcher P , Spry E , Macdonald JA , et al. Adolescent antecedents of maternal and paternal perinatal depression: a 36-year prospective cohort . Psychol Med . 2021 ;51 (12 ):2126 –33 . doi: 10.1017/S0033291720000902
32340651
3Hossain MM , Nesa F , Das J , Aggad R , Tasnim S , Bairwa M , et al. Global burden of mental health problems among children and adolescents during COVID-19 pandemic: An umbrella review . Psychiatry Res . 2022 ;317 :114814 . doi: 10.1016/j.psychres.2022.114814 36055064 PMC9420079
4Priess HA , Lindberg SM , Hyde JS . Adolescent gender-role identity and mental health: gender intensification revisited . Child Dev . 2009 ;80 (5 ):1531 –44 . doi: 10.1111/j.1467-8624.2009.01349.x
19765016 PMC4244905
5Blum RW , Mmari K , Moreau C . It Begins at 10: how gender expectations shape early adolescence around the world . J Adolesc Health . 2017 ;61 (4 Suppl):S3–4 . doi: 10.1016/j.jadohealth.2017.07.009
28915989 PMC5612023
6European Institute for Gender Equality. Gender socialisation. European Institute for Gender Equality. 2016 . https://eige.europa.eu/publications-resources/thesaurus/terms/1091?language_content_entity=en
7Nartey P , Bahar OS , Nabunya P . A Review of the cultural gender norms contributing to gender inequality in Ghana: An ecological systems perspective . J Int Womens Stud . 2023 ;25 (7 ):14 . 38736590 PMC11086636
8Martin CL , Ruble DN . Patterns of gender development . Annu Rev Psychol . 2010 ;61 :353 –81 . doi: 10.1146/annurev.psych.093008.100511
19575615 PMC3747736
9Kågesten A , Gibbs S , Blum RW , Moreau C , Chandra-Mouli V , Herbert A , et al. Understanding factors that shape gender attitudes in early adolescence globally: a mixed-methods systematic review . PLoS One . 2016 ;11 (6 ):e0157805. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0157805 27341206 PMC4920358
10Weber AM , Cislaghi B , Meausoone V , Abdalla S , Mejía-Guevara I , Loftus P , et al. Gender norms and health: insights from global survey data . Lancet . 2019 ;393 (10189 ):2455 –68 . doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(19)30765-2
31155273
11Davis SN , Greenstein TN . Gender ideology: Components, predictors, and consequences . Annu Rev Sociol . 2009 ;35 (1 ):87 –105 .
12Khalaf AM , Alubied AA , Khalaf AM , Rifaey AA . The impact of social media on the mental health of adolescents and young adults: a systematic review . Cureus . 2023 ;15 (8 ):e42990. doi: 10.7759/cureus.42990 37671234 PMC10476631
13Santoniccolo F , Trombetta T , Paradiso MN , Rollè L . Gender and media representations: a review of the literature on gender stereotypes, objectification and sexualization . Int J Environ Res Public Health . 2023 ;20 (10 ):5770 . doi: 10.3390/ijerph20105770 37239498 PMC10218532
14Zábó V , Erát D , Vargha A , Vincze Á , Harangozó J , Iváncsics M , et al. Mental health competencies are stronger determinants of well-being than mental disorder symptoms in both psychiatric and non-clinical samples . Sci Rep . 2024 ;14 (1 ):12943 . doi: 10.1038/s41598-024-63674-9 38839972 PMC11153550
15Alaze A , Grosser J , Razum O , Miani C . Gender and mental health of adolescents: a conceptual framework developed in a Delphi study . 2025 .10.1371/journal.pone.0318394 PMC12704890 41396894
16Delgado-Herrera M , Aceves-Gómez AC , Reyes-Aguilar A . Relationship between gender roles, motherhood beliefs and mental health . PLoS One . 2024 ;19 (3 ):e0298750. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0298750 38507331 PMC10954095
17Lederer V , Messing K , Sultan-Taïeb H . How can quantitative analysis be used to improve occupational health without reinforcing social inequalities? an examination of statistical methods . Int J Environ Res Public Health . 2022 ;20 (1 ):19 . doi: 10.3390/ijerph20010019 36612341 PMC9819275
18Reisen CA , Brooks KD , Zea MC , Poppen PJ , Bianchi FT . Can additive measures add to an intersectional understanding? Experiences of gay and ethnic discrimination among HIV-positive Latino gay men . Cultur Divers Ethnic Minor Psychol . 2013 ;19 (2 ):208 –17 . doi: 10.1037/a0031906
23647331 PMC3823050
19Liao L , Zhang Y , He X , Yang X , Long H , Tan L , et al. Structural equation modeling for influencing factors with quality care behavior among nursing assistants: a cross-sectional study . BMC Nurs . 2025 ;24 (1 ):280 . doi: 10.1186/s12912-025-02894-4 40082950 PMC11905681
20Goretzko D , Siemund K , Sterner P . Evaluating model fit of measurement models in confirmatory factor analysis . Educ Psychol Meas . 2024 ;84 (1 ):123 –44 . doi: 10.1177/00131644231163813
38250508 PMC10795573
21Hamory J , Jones N , Woldehanna T , Baird S . GAGE Ethiopia Round 2 Quantitative Research Design and Sample . London. 2023 . https://doc.ukdataservice.ac.uk/doc/9196/mrdoc/pdf/9196_gage_ethiopia_r2_manual_designandsamplev1.pdf
22Baird S , Bhutta ZA , Hamad BA , Hicks JH , Jones N , Muz J . Do restrictive gender attitudes and norms influence physical and mental health during very young Adolescence? Evidence from Bangladesh and Ethiopia . SSM Popul Health . 2019 ;9 :100480 . doi: 10.1016/j.ssmph.2019.100480 31993481 PMC6978471
23Alaze A , Grosser J , Razum O , Miani C . How does a recent gender norms scale perform? Exploratory factor analyses among adolescents in Ethiopia and Bangladesh . PLOS Glob Public Health . 2025 ;5 (10 ):e0005190. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0005190 41100553 PMC12530582
24Comotti A , Fattori A , Greselin F , Bordini L , Brambilla P , Bonzini M . Psychometric Evaluation of GHQ-12 as a screening tool for psychological impairment of healthcare workers facing COVID-19 pandemic . Med Lav . 2023 ;114 (1 ):e2023009. doi: 10.23749/mdl.v114i1.13918 36790406 PMC9987474
25Hu L , Bentler PM . Cutoff criteria for fit indexes in covariance structure analysis: Conventional criteria versus new alternatives . Structural Equation Modeling: A Multidisciplinary Journal . 1999 ;6 (1 ):1 –55 . doi: 10.1080/10705519909540118
26McNeish D , An J , Hancock GR . The thorny relation between measurement quality and fit index cutoffs in latent variable models . J Pers Assess . 2018 ;100 (1 ):43 –52 . doi: 10.1080/00223891.2017.1281286
28631976
27Rosseel Y , Jorgensen TD , Wilde L de . Lavaan: Latent Variable Analysis . 2025 .
28Schreiber JB . Core reporting practices in structural equation modeling . Res Social Adm Pharm . 2008 ;4 (2 ):83 –97 . doi: 10.1016/j.sapharm.2007.04.003
18555963
29Baksheev GN , Robinson J , Cosgrave EM , Baker K , Yung AR . Validity of the 12-item General Health Questionnaire (GHQ-12) in detecting depressive and anxiety disorders among high school students . Psychiatry Res . 2011 ;187 (1–2):291 –6 . doi: 10.1016/j.psychres.2010.10.010
21067813
30Kim JH . Multicollinearity and misleading statistical results . Korean J Anesthesiol . 2019 ;72 (6 ):558 –69 . doi: 10.4097/kja.19087
31304696 PMC6900425
31Kolhar M , Kazi RNA , Alameen A . Effect of social media use on learning, social interactions, and sleep duration among university students . Saudi J Biol Sci . 2021 ;28 (4 ):2216 –22 . doi: 10.1016/j.sjbs.2021.01.010
33911938 PMC8071811
32Wicker P , Cunningham GB . Gender stereotypes and their correlates: the moderating role of voluntary sports club membership . Front Psychol . 2023 ;14 :1236439 . doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1236439 37744577 PMC10513099
33Cortellazzo L , Bonesso S , Gerli F , Pizzi C . Experiences that matter: unraveling the link between extracurricular activities and emotional and social competencies . Front Psychol . 2021 ;12 :659526 . doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.659526 34489783 PMC8416762
34Campbell OLK , Bann D , Patalay P . The gender gap in adolescent mental health: A cross-national investigation of 566,829 adolescents across 73 countries . SSM Popul Health . 2021 ;13 :100742 . doi: 10.1016/j.ssmph.2021.100742 33748389 PMC7960541
35Hopcroft RL , Bradley DB . The sex difference in depression across 29 countries . Social Forces . 2007 ;85 (4 ):1483 –507 .
36Saeed Ali T , Karmaliani R , Mcfarlane J , Khuwaja HMA , Somani Y , Chirwa ED , et al. Attitude towards gender roles and violence against women and girls (VAWG): baseline findings from an RCT of 1752 youths in Pakistan . Glob Health Action . 2017 ;10 (1 ):1342454 . doi: 10.1080/16549716.2017.1342454 28758882 PMC5964875
37Bauer GR , Churchill SM , Mahendran M , Walwyn C , Lizotte D , Villa-Rueda AA . Intersectionality in quantitative research: A systematic review of its emergence and applications of theory and methods . SSM Popul Health . 2021 ;14 :100798 . doi: 10.1016/j.ssmph.2021.100798 33997247 PMC8095182
38Fairchild AJ , McDaniel HL . Best (but oft-forgotten) practices: mediation analysis . Am J Clin Nutr . 2017 ;105 (6 ):1259 –71 . doi: 10.3945/ajcn.117.152546
28446497 PMC5445681
39Stone BM . The ethical use of fit indices in structural equation modeling: recommendations for psychologists . Front Psychol . 2021 ;12 :783226 . doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.783226 34887821 PMC8650002
40Mai AS , Wan Y-M , Tan BJ-W , Tan E-K . Solving the gender paradox in adolescent suicide: challenges and directions . Front Psychiatry . 2024 ;15 :1386153 . doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2024.1386153 38962059 PMC11219559
Come citare questo studio
Alaze A, Hagen D, Schamberger T, Razum O, Miani C. (2026). Gendered pathways to adolescent mental health: An empirical assessment of a new conceptual framework.. PLOS global public health. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0006728
Consulta la pubblicazione originale ↗