20 Novembre 2026

Psicologia Punto One | Psicologia e Psicologi nel Web

Menu

Menu

SCHEDA SCIENTIFICA2026Altra ricerca

The resource elasticity of control.

Solomyak L, Emanuel A, Eldar E

eLife · 2026

Abstract originale

The ability to determine how much the environment can be controlled through our actions has long been viewed as fundamental to adaptive behavior. While traditional accounts treat controllability as a fixed property of the environment, we argue that real-world controllability often depends on the effort, time, and money we are able and willing to invest. In such cases, controllability can be said to be elastic to invested resources. Here, we propose that inferring this elasticity is essential for efficient resource allocation, and thus, elasticity misestimations result in maladaptive behavior. To test this hypothesis, we developed a novel treasure hunt game where participants encountered environments with varying degrees of controllability and elasticity. Across two pre-registered studies (N=514), we first demonstrate that people infer elasticity and adapt their resource allocation accordingly. We then present a computational model that explains how people make this inference and identify individual elasticity biases that lead to suboptimal resource allocation. Finally, we show that overestimation of elasticity is associated with elevated psychopathology involving an impaired sense of control. These findings establish the elasticity of control as a distinct cognitive construct guiding adaptive behavior and a computational marker for control-related maladaptive behavior.

Parole chiave

HumanNeuroscienceControllabilitydecision-makingPsychopathologyReinforcement LearningHumansAdaptation, PsychologicalDecision MakingResource AllocationFemaleSense of Agency
Leggi il testo integrale originale

Testo estratto dalla pubblicazione: sono esclusi immagini, media, supplementi e parti soggette a diritti distinti.

The resource elasticity of control

The ability to determine how much the environment can be controlled through our actions has long been viewed as fundamental to adaptive behavior. While traditional accounts treat controllability as a fixed property of the environment, we argue that real-world controllability often depends on the effort, time, and money we are able and willing to invest. In such cases, controllability can be said to be elastic to invested resources. Here, we propose that inferring this elasticity is essential for efficient resource allocation, and thus, elasticity misestimations result in maladaptive behavior. To test this hypothesis, we developed a novel treasure hunt game where participants encountered environments with varying degrees of controllability and elasticity. Across two pre-registered studies (N=514), we first demonstrate that people infer elasticity and adapt their resource allocation accordingly. We then present a computational model that explains how people make this inference and identify individual elasticity biases that lead to suboptimal resource allocation. Finally, we show that overestimation of elasticity is associated with elevated psychopathology involving an impaired sense of control. These findings establish the elasticity of control as a distinct cognitive construct guiding adaptive behavior and a computational marker for control-related maladaptive behavior.

Introduction

Taking action requires us to invest resources, such as time, money, and effort, and is thus only sensible if our actions have the potential to change the environment to our advantage. Accurate estimation of this potential – i.e., of the environment’s controllability (Ligneul et al., 2022; Ligneul, 2021; Raab et al., 2022; Liljeholm, 2021) – enables us to make informed decisions as to whether to engage in action (Moscarello and Hartley, 2017; Dorfman and Gershman, 2019; Wang et al., 2021; Chambon et al., 2020). Misestimations of controllability thus result in maladaptive behavior and contribute to mental health disorders such as depression, anxiety, and obsessive-compulsive disorder (Diener et al., 2009; Moulding and Kyrios, 2006; Gallagher et al., 2014; Salkovskis, 1996; McLaren and Crowe, 2003).

The degree of control we possess over our environment, however, may itself depend on the resources we are willing and able to invest. For example, the control a biker has over their commute time depends on the power they are willing and able to invest in pedaling. In this respect, a highly trained biker would typically have more control than a novice. Likewise, the control a diner in a restaurant has over their meal may depend on how much money they have to spend. In such situations, controllability is not fixed but rather elastic to available resources (i.e. in the same sense that supply and demand may be elastic to changing prices; Pindyck, 2018).

To formalize how elasticity relates to control, we build on an established definition of controllability as the fraction of reward that is controllably achievable, χ (Huys and Dayan, 2009). Uncertainty about this fraction could result from uncertainty about the amount of resources that the agent is able and willing to invest, maxCmaxC. Elasticity can thus be defined as the amount of information obtained about controllability by knowing the amount of available resources: I(χ;maxC)\begin{document}$I\left (\chi ;maxC\right)$\end{document}.

While only controllable environments can be elastic, the inverse is not necessarily true – controllability can be high, yet inelastic to invested resources – e.g., choosing between bus routes affords equal control over commute time to anyone who can afford the basic fare (Figure 1; Supplementary Note 1). That said, since all actions require some resource investment, no controllable environment is completely inelastic when considering the full spectrum of possible agents, including those with insufficient resources to act (e.g. those unable to purchase a bus fare or pay for a fixed-price meal). Even in this case, however, controllability can be elastic to varying degrees.

Knowing the elasticity of control is necessary for deciding whether and how to act. Failing to achieve one’s goal, for example, should only lead one to invest more resources in an elastic environment. Critically, in many real-life domains (e.g. studying for an exam), we must use our experiences to infer the degree to which we can improve our control by investing more resources (Sullivan-Toole et al., 2016; Schunk, 1982; Frömer et al., 2021; Cao et al., 2022; Grahek et al., 2023; Shenhav et al., 2021; Inzlicht et al., 2018). Failure to do so is bound to result in maladaptive behavior and may thus contribute to mental health disorders. Depressed patients, for instance, are less willing to expend their resources to obtain control (Grahek et al., 2019; Cohen et al., 1982; Bi et al., 2022), which could reflect an underestimation of elasticity. Conversely, the repetitive and unusual amount of effort invested by people with obsessive-compulsive disorder in attempts to exert control (Gillan et al., 2014; Reuven-Magril et al., 2008) could indicate an overestimation of elasticity, i.e., a belief that adequate control can only be achieved through excessive and repeated resource investment (Reuven-Magril et al., 2008). Ultimately, not having a good grasp of how additional efforts influence the success of one’s actions is bound to undermine one’s sense of agency (SOA) (Sullivan-Toole et al., 2016; Schunk, 1982).

Thus, here, we ask whether and how people infer the elasticity of control over their environment. We hypothesize that individual differences in elasticity inference lead to a mismanagement of one’s resources when attempting to control the environment and are thus associated with psychopathologies involving a distorted sense of control (Grahek et al., 2019; Zorowitz et al., 2020; Gillan et al., 2014; Reuven-Magril et al., 2008).

Experimental paradigms to date have conflated overall controllability and its elasticity, such that controllability was either low or elastic (Sullivan-Toole et al., 2016; Schunk, 1982; Frömer et al., 2021; Cao et al., 2022; Grahek et al., 2023; Shenhav et al., 2021; Inzlicht et al., 2018). The elasticity of control, however, must be dissociated from overall controllability to accurately diagnose mismanagement of resources. A given individual, for instance, may tend to overinvest resources because they overestimate controllability – e.g., exercising due to a misguided belief that this can make one taller when, in fact, height cannot be controlled. Alternatively, they may do so because they overestimate the elasticity of control – e.g., a chess expert practicing unnecessarily hard to win against a novice when their existing skill level already ensures control over the match’s outcome. Identifying which misestimation drives resource mismanagement requires an experimental design that independently manipulates overall controllability from its elasticity.

Therefore, here, we dissociate elastic and inelastic controllability using a novel treasure-hunt game where participants encountered three distinct environments: The first offered high elastic controllability, where a high level of control can only be attained by investing extra resources. The second offered high inelastic controllability, where control is attainable with any level of resource investment. And the third offered low controllability, where control was not attainable despite any level of resource investment. In each environment, participants were allowed to invest various amounts of resources to pursue reward or to altogether forgo pursuing reward. Examining how participants adapted their resource investment to observed outcomes enabled us to determine whether and how participants inferred each environment’s controllability and its elasticity.

Across two pre-registered studies (N=514), we establish that people do indeed infer the elasticity of control. We present a computational model that explains how people make this inference and identify individual biases in its implementation. We thus show that elasticity overestimation leads to an overinvestment of resources and is associated with elevated psychopathology involving an impaired sense of control. These findings establish elasticity as a crucial dimension of controllability that guides adaptive behavior and a computational marker of control-related psychopathology.

Results

We had online participants (first study = 264, replication study = 250, ages = 18–45, mean 33±0.6) play a novel treasure-hunt game set across multiple planets. On each trip (trial), participants attempted to travel from an initial location (‘desert’ or ‘fountain’) to a treasure (worth 150 coins; 15¢ of monetary compensation), located at either the house or the mountain (Figure 2A). Participants could exercise control by boarding the train to reach the house or the plane to reach the mountain (right-hand side, Figure 2B). The present planet’s controllability determined the probability that participants would succeed in boarding the vehicle they selected. In high-controllability planets, participants consistently boarded their preferred vehicle, enabling them to reliably reach their destination. Conversely, in low-controllability planets, participants frequently failed to board and were thus forced to walk to the nearest location. On 20% of trials, the nearest location was where the treasure was located, thus partially decoupling success in exerting control from reward.

To investigate how people learn the elasticity of control, we allowed participants to invest different amounts of resources in attempting to board their preferred vehicle. Participants could purchase 1 (40 coins), 2 (60 coins), or 3 tickets (80 coins) or otherwise walk for free to the nearest location. Participants were informed that a single ticket allowed them to board only if the vehicle stopped at the station, while additional tickets provided extra chances to board even after the vehicle had left the platform. For each additional ticket, the chosen vehicle appeared moving from left to right across the screen, and participants could attempt to board it by pressing the spacebar when it reached the center of the screen. Thus, each additional ticket could increase the chance of boarding but also required a greater investment of resources – decreasing earnings, extending the trial duration, and demanding attentional effort to precisely time a button press when attempting to board.

Participants received no feedback about individual boarding attempts but were shown their initial and final locations at the end of each trip, enabling them to infer whether they had successfully boarded their vehicle. For simplicity, we defined inelastic controllability as the probability that even 1 ticket would lead to successfully boarding the vehicle and elastic controllability as the degree to which 2 extra tickets would increase that probability.

To dissociate elastic from inelastic controllability, each participant visited three randomly sampled planets. In the first planet, controllability was high and inelastic, meaning that no matter how many tickets you purchased, you had a good chance of making your ride (sampled from the green area in Figure 2D). In the second planet, controllability was high and elastic, meaning that you needed to purchase 2 extra tickets to have a good chance of making your ride (Figure 2D, blue). And in the third planet, controllability was low, meaning that no matter how many tickets you purchased, you did not have a good chance of making your ride (Figure 2D, red).

Importantly, the order of these planets was randomized, and participants did not know in advance which planet they were visiting. Thus, they could only infer a planet’s controllability and elasticity from the outcomes of their actions. Moreover, to increase sensitivity to individual biases, we had all participants visit a fourth planet where purchasing any number of tickets (0, 1, 2, 3) was equally optimal (Figure 2D, black circle). We also homogenized participants’ initial learning experiences by giving them 3 free tickets for the first five visits to every planet. As we shall see below, this latter measure also helped dissociate between different models of how participants solved the task.

People adapt to the elasticity of control

To determine whether participants inferred the elasticity of control, we first examined how they adapted their resource investment across planets. We found that participants were more likely to purchase tickets (‘opt in’) in more controllable planets, whether controllability was elastic (initial and replication studies, p<0.001; mixed logistic regression) or inelastic (initial and replication studies, p<0.001; Figure 3A and C). Conversely, participants purchased more extra tickets only in planets with high elastic controllability (initial p=0.01, replication p=0.004; mixed probit regression; Figure 3B and C). Although substantial individual differences were observed in this regard (Figure 3D), these results show that most participants successfully adapted to both the controllability of the environments they visited and its elasticity.

People infer the elasticity of control

That participants adapted to each environment does not necessarily mean they inferred the elasticity of control (nor that they inferred control at all, but see Methods for how this was verified). Successful adaptation to the elasticity of control may also be achieved merely by treating each possible level of resource investment as a separate course of action. One could thus learn the degree of control afforded by each course of action (i.e. purchasing 1, 2, or 3 tickets), and then choose the one that affords the highest expected value considering its cost. This simple strategy could achieve optimal performance given unlimited experience. However, it would not be as efficient as a strategy that employs elasticity inference, because it does not make use of the dependencies that exist between different levels of resource investment in the degrees of control they afford. Thus, upon failing to board a vehicle despite purchasing 3 tickets, the simpler strategy would need to purchase 1 or 2 tickets to know these options would fail as well, whereas an agent equipped with the concept of elasticity would conclude that controllability is low, and it is thus best to opt out. Conversely, upon succeeding to board with 3 tickets, the simpler strategy would tend to favor purchasing 3 tickets over 1 or 2 tickets, even if the extra tickets confer no benefit, whereas an agent that infers elasticity would not favor 3 over 1 or 2 tickets because it received no evidence that controllability is elastic (i.e. that the extra tickets help).

To determine which of these models best describes the way participants solved the task, we formalized the simpler strategy as the ‘controllability model,’ and an elasticity-inferring strategy as the ‘elastic controllability model’ (pre-registered at https://aspredicted.org/CHW_12H). Both models use beta distributions, characterized by parameters a and b, to represent the probability of boarding when purchasing different numbers of tickets, but only the elastic controllability model learns latent elasticity estimates. Specifically, in the ‘controllability model’, three beta distributions represent the expected level of control from purchasing 1, 2, or 3 tickets. Thus, the parameters of these distributions (an,bn,n∈{1,2,3}\begin{document}$a_{n},b_{n},n\in \left \{1,2,3\right \}$\end{document}) accumulate the number of times each number of tickets led (an\begin{document}$a_{n}$\end{document}) or did not lead (bn\begin{document}$b_{n}$\end{document}) to successful boarding. Conversely, in the ‘elastic controllability model’, the beta distributions represent a belief about the maximum achievable level of control (acontrol,bcontrol\begin{document}$a_{control},b_{control}$\end{document}) coupled with two elasticity estimates that specify the degree to which successful boarding requires purchasing at least 1 (aelastic≥1,belastic≥1\begin{document}$a_{elastic\geq 1},b_{elastic\geq 1}$\end{document}) or specifically 2 (aelastic2,belastic2\begin{document}$a_{elastic2},b_{elastic2}$\end{document}) extra tickets. As such, these elasticity estimates quantify how resource investment affects control. The higher they are, the more controllability estimates can be made more precise by knowing how much resources the agent is willing and able to invest (Supplementary Note 1). Figure 4 shows schematically how the two models differ in updating their estimates in response to different types of outcomes. Both models similarly use these estimates to compute an expected value for purchasing 0, 1, 2, or 3 tickets, and accordingly choose between these options (see Methods for model equations and Appendix 1—table 3 for all parameter fits, priors, and their interpretation).

Examining the predictions of both models, each simulated using the parameter setting that best fit participants’ choices, showed that the elastic-controllability model was better than the controllability model at opting-out in low-controllability planets (elastic-controllability model % opt in 49% ± 0.01, controllability model % opt in 63% ± 0.01; Figure 5C, top panel). Most importantly, this higher level of performance closely matched participants’ behavior (% opt in 47% ± 0.02). Furthermore, the elastic controllability model was also better at not purchasing extra tickets in low-controllability (elastic controllability extra tickets = 0.49 ± 0.01 controllability extra tickets = 0.65 ± 0.01) and inelastic-controllability (elastic controllability extra tickets = 0.58 ± 0.01 controllability extra tickets = 0.66 ± 0.01) planets, and this too was more closely aligned with participants’ behavior (low-controllability extra tickets = 51 ± 0.002, inelastic-controllability extra tickets = 53 ± 0.02; Figure 5C, bottom panel).

Beyond these general aspects of task behavior, having participants start on every planet with free 3-ticket trips also enabled us to examine their response to succeeding or failing with 3 tickets, prior to any other experiences on the planet (Figure 5D). As noted above, failure with 3 tickets makes the controllability model favor 1 and 2 tickets over 3 tickets, whereas success with 3 tickets makes it favor 3 tickets over 1 and 2 tickets. Critically, neither the participants nor the simulation of the elastic controllability model showed these effects. Upon failing with 3 tickets, both participants and the elastic model primarily favored to opt out. Conversely, if they succeeded with 3 tickets, they did not become less likely to purchase 1 or 2 tickets.

In fact, failure with 3 tickets even made participants favor 3, over 1 and 2, tickets. This favoring of 3 tickets continued until participants accumulated sufficient evidence about their limited control to opt out (Appendix 1—figure 2). Presumably, the initial failures with 3 tickets resulted in increased uncertainty about whether it is at all possible to control one’s destination. Consequently, participants who nevertheless opted in invested maximum resources to resolve this uncertainty before exploring whether control is elastic. While this behavior directly contradicts the controllability model, it also goes beyond the behavior exhibited by the elastic controllability model. To capture this aspect of participants’ behavior, we modified the elastic controllability model (elastic controllability*) such that it would increase its elasticity estimates when controllability is reduced. Model comparison consistently supported this modification (initial study: log Bayes factor = 143 replication study: log Bayes factor = 155).

More importantly, both the original and modified elastic controllability models explained participants’ behavior better than the controllability model (initial: log Bayes factor ≥270; replication: log Bayes factor ≥148; Figure 5E) as well as other theoretically motivated alternatives (see Methods). These results establish that people infer the elasticity of control and thereby adapt their resource allocation to the environment’s controllability and its elasticity.

Individual elasticity biases explain misallocation of resources

To determine whether the elastic controllability* model could identify individual biases in elasticity inference, we fitted the model to participants’ choices and thus derived each participant’s beliefs about controllability (γcontrollability\begin{document}$\gamma _{controllability}$\end{document}) and elasticity (γelasticity\begin{document}$\gamma _{elasticity}$\end{document}) prior to visiting any planet. γcontrollability\begin{document}$\gamma _{controllability}$\end{document} is used to initialize the model’s belief about the maximum available control (acontrol\begin{document}$a_{control}$\end{document}, bcontrol\begin{document}$b_{control}$\end{document}), with higher values reflecting stronger prior beliefs that planets are controllable. γelasticity\begin{document}$\gamma _{elasticity}$\end{document} is used to initialize the model’s elasticity estimates (aelastic\begin{document}$a_{elastic}$\end{document}, belastic\begin{document}$b_{elastic}$\end{document}), with higher values reflecting stronger prior beliefs that control is elastic (see Methods). The stronger the belief, the greater its influence on choices to opt in (γcontrollability\begin{document}$\gamma _{controllability}$\end{document}) and purchase extra tickets (γelasticity\begin{document}$\gamma _{elasticity}$\end{document}) regardless of observed outcomes. In addition to these two model parameters, we examined four additional parameters that directly influence opting-in and the purchase of extra tickets. These include an inverse temperature parameter (β), which specifies the stochasticity with which expected values affect resource investment choices, and baseline preference parameters for purchasing 1, 2, or 3 tickets (α1, α2, α3). Across both samples, shared variance among parameters never exceeded 14% (Appendix 1—figure 1) and was particularly low for the controllability and elasticity priors (initial study: 5%; replication study: 3%). Thus, a tendency to assume the environment is controllable did not imply a tendency to assume that control is elastic, establishing inferences concerning maximum controllability and its elasticity as distinct facets of individual differences.

To clarify how fitted model parameters related to observable behavior, we regressed participants’ opt-in rates and extra ticket purchases on the parameters (Figure 6A). We found that a higher controllability bias (higher γcontrollability\begin{document}$\gamma _{controllability}$\end{document}) was associated with more opting in (initial study p<0.001; replication study p<0.02; logistic regression) and more extra tickets purchased (initial p<0.001; replication p<0.001; probit regression) on low-controllability, as compared to high-controllability, planets. Thus, a prior assumption that control is likely available (operationalized by γcontrollability\begin{document}$\gamma _{controllability}$\end{document}) was reflected in a futile investment of resources in uncontrollable environments.

In contrast, a higher elasticity bias was associated with the purchasing of more extra tickets on planets with inelastic, as compared to elastic, controllability (initial study: β=0.18,95%CI=[0.03,0.34],p=0.02\begin{document}$\beta =0.18,95{\%} \, CI=\left [0.03,0.34\right ], \, {\rm p}=0.02$\end{document}; replication study: β=0.15,95%CI=[0.020.28],p=0.02;\begin{document}$\beta =0.15,95 {\% } \, CI=\left [0.02 \, 0.28\right],\, {\rm p}=0.02;$\end{document} linear regression). Thus, a prior assumption that control is likely elastic available (operationalized by γelasticity\begin{document}$\gamma _{elasticity}$\end{document}) was primarily reflected in a needless investment of extra resources in environments where control could be obtained more cheaply.

Other parameters showed associations consistent with their roles in the model. Specifically, the inverse temperature parameter (β) was associated with a more optimal allocation of resources, all three baseline preference parameters (α1, α2, α3) were associated with opting in, and α2 and α3, in particular, were also associated with the purchasing of more extra tickets (Figure 6A).

In sum, the model parameters captured meaningful individual differences in how participants allocated their resources across environments, with the controllability parameter primarily explaining variance in resource allocation in uncontrollable environments, and the elasticity parameter primarily explaining variance in resource allocation in environments where control was inelastic.

Individual elasticity biases are associated with psychopathology

To examine whether the individual biases in controllability and elasticity inference have psychopathological ramifications, we assayed participants on a range of self-report measures of psychopathologies previously linked to a distorted sense of control (see Methods). Examining the direct correlations between model parameters and psychopathology measures (reported in Appendix 1—figure 3) does not account for the substantial variance that is typically shared among different forms of psychopathology. For this reason, we instead used a canonical correlation analysis (CCA) to identify particular dimensions within the parameter and psychopathology spaces that most strongly correlate with one another. The CCA loadings indicate the contribution of each parameter of psychopathology score to the overall canonical correlation. We assessed statistical significance of the canonical correlation against a null distribution obtained by permuting the model parameter relative to the psychopathology scores. This showed that the correlation was significant in both the initial (p=0.01) and the replication (p=0.02) studies.

To obtain more robust estimates of the CCA loadings, we next ran a CCA on both datasets combined (Figure 6C, ρ=0.33, p=0.004). On the side of model parameters, the elasticity prior parameter (γelasticity\begin{document}$\gamma _{elasticity}$\end{document}) received the highest loading. By comparison, the controllability prior parameter received a lower loading with the opposite sign. A further permutation test showed that the contribution of the elasticity prior parameter to the parameter-psychopathology correlation was itself significant (p=0.04; Figure 6D).

Loadings on the side of psychopathology were dominated by an impaired SOA (contribution to canonical correlation: p=0.03, Figure 6D, bottom plot), along with obsessive-compulsive disorder and social anxiety (Liebowitz Social Anxiety Scale [LSAS]) – all symptoms that have been linked to an impaired sense of control (Gillan et al., 2014; Reuven-Magril et al., 2008; Beyer et al., 2018). Conversely, depression scores (Self-Rating Depression Scale [SDS]) received a negative loading, consistent with evidence of a lower willingness to expend one’s resources in depression (Grahek et al., 2019; Cohen et al., 1982; Bi et al., 2022). This psychopathological profile also manifested in raw task measures, since, like the elasticity prior parameter, it too was associated with the purchasing of more tickets on planets where controllability was less elastic (initial: β=0.19,95%CI=[0.06,0.32],\begin{document}$\beta =0.19,95\% \, CI=\left [0.06,0.32\right],$\end{document} p=0.004; replication: β=0.13,95%CI=[0.01,0.25],p=0.03;\begin{document}$\beta =0.13,95{\%} CI=\left [0.01,0.25\right ],{\rm p}=0.03;$\end{document} linear regression; Figure 6A). Thus, a distinct psychopathological profile involving a distorted SOA was associated with a bias in elasticity inference.

Discussion

Across two pre-registered studies, we demonstrate that humans infer the elasticity of control over their present environment, and this informs their decisions of whether and how to act. Accordingly, we found that a bias to overestimate the elasticity of control leads to a mismanagement of resources and is associated with elevated psychopathology involving an impaired SOA.

Unlike prior work that treated controllability and its elasticity as coupled, our studies dissociated elastic and inelastic controllability, revealing that individuals who typically assume that taking action is worthwhile (overall controllability) do not necessarily assume that investing more resources in taking action is worthwhile (the elasticity of control). In fact, biases regarding controllability and its elasticity were oppositely related to psychopathology, revealing a psychopathological profile that combines underestimation of control with overestimation of the degree to which investing more resources is necessary to obtain control.

The observed elasticity biases across individuals are particularly striking given the simplicity of the experimental task in comparison to real-life scenarios. Unlike the task, where successful boarding directly determined a trip’s outcome, in many real situations, many actions may contribute to a single outcome. In this regard, the present work introduces a new kind of credit-assignment problem (Sutton, 1984), which involves identifying not only which actions influenced the outcome but also which of these actions was made more effective by investing more resources in its execution. Moreover, whereas in the task, elasticity increased linearly with the number of tickets, resource investment in real life often exhibits nonlinear effects. Specifically, further increases in resource investment often result in diminishing returns, and beyond a certain point, even worse outcomes (e.g. hiring too many employees, making the work less efficient). Additionally, real life typically doesn’t offer the streamlined recurrence of homogenized experiences that makes learning easier in experimental tasks, nor are people systematically instructed and trained about elastic and inelastic control in each environment. These complexities introduce substantial additional uncertainty into inferences of elasticity in naturalistic settings, thus allowing more room for prior biases to exert their influences. The elasticity biases observed in the present studies are therefore likely to be amplified in real-life behavior. Future research should examine how these complexities affect judgments about the elasticity of control to better understand how people allocate resources in real life.

Our finding that elasticity biases are associated with agency-related psychopathologies raises interesting questions for future research on the causal nature of this association. One possibility is that biased elasticity inferences distort one’s SOA by leading to maladaptive resource allocation that results in consistently suboptimal outcomes. Another possibility is that people who already have a reduced SOA attempt to compensate for this feeling by investing more resources despite minimal benefit, thus demonstrating an elasticity bias. Importantly, these possibilities are not mutually exclusive. That is, elasticity biases and a distorted SOA could reinforce each other in a cyclical manner. Longitudinal studies tracking or manipulating elasticity beliefs while monitoring changes in real-life resource investment and subjective SOA could resolve how elasticity biases and psychopathology influence each other.

Whereas our pre-registered CCA effectively identified associations between task parameters and a psychopathological profile, this analysis method does not directly reveal relationships between individual variables. Auxiliary analyses confirmed significant contributions of both elasticity bias and SOA to the observed canonical correlation, but the contribution of other measures remains to be determined by future work. Such work could employ other established measures of agency, including both behavioral indices and subjective self-reports, to better understand how these constructs relate across different contexts and populations.

Our operationalization of controllability aligns with previous work that defined controllability as the degree to which actions influence the probability of obtaining a reward (Moscarello and Hartley, 2017; Dorfman and Gershman, 2019; Dorfman and Gershman, 2019). Other notable works defined controllability as the degree to which actions predict subsequent states, independent of reward (Ligneul et al., 2022; Ligneul, 2021; Raab et al., 2022) Here, we adhered to the former definition due to our present focus on resource elasticity, since individuals are unlikely to invest resources to gain control if control does not yield more reward. That said, we followed the latter work in ensuring that controllability is not confounded with predictability (Ligneul, 2021), in the sense that in planets with high controllability, outcomes were not necessarily more predictable than in planets with low controllability (see Methods). This enabled us to specifically assess individual inferences concerning controllability and its resource elasticity.

Future research could explore alternative models for implementing elasticity inference that extend beyond our current paradigm. First, further investigation is warranted concerning how uncertainty about controllability and its elasticity interact. In the present study, we minimized individual differences in the estimation of maximum available control by providing participants with 3 free tickets at their initial visits to each planet. We made this design choice to isolate differences in the estimation of elasticity, as opposed to maximum controllability. To study how these two types of estimations interact, future work could benefit from modifying this aspect of our experimental design.

Second, future models could enable generalization to levels of resource investment not previously experienced. For example, controllability and its elasticity could be jointly estimated via function approximation that considers control as a function of invested resources. Although our implementation of this model did not fit participants’ choices well (see Methods), other modeling assumptions drawn from human functional learning (Li et al., 2023) or experimental designs with continuous action spaces may offer a better test of this idea.

Another interesting possibility is that individual elasticity biases vary across different resource types (e.g. money, time, effort). For instance, a given individual may assume that controllability tends to be highly elastic to money but inelastic to effort. Although the task incorporated multiple resource types (money, time, and attentional effort), the results may differ depending on the type of resources on which the participant focuses. Future studies could explore this possibility by developing tasks that separately manipulate elasticity with respect to different resource types. This would clarify whether elasticity biases are domain-specific or domain-general, and thus elucidate their impact on everyday decision-making.

Methods

Pre-registration

Both the initial and replication studies were pre-registered prior to data collection. The pre-registrations included hypotheses, sample sizes, exclusion criteria, task design, analysis plans (regressions, CCA), and computational models. Detailed pre-registration documents are available at https://aspredicted.org/Q7M_BHR and https://aspredicted.org/CHW_12H.

Participants

We used the Prolific online platform (prolific.com) to recruit participants (initial study N=264; replication study N=250). Participants were selected based on their demonstrated high engagement levels in prior studies, fluency in English, and absence of psychiatric diagnoses. Due to cultural differences in the perception of controllability (Msetfi et al., 2015), participants were recruited from English-speaking western countries. The average age of participants across both datasets was 33 years of age (SE = 0.6), and 38% were female.

The sample size was determined using a power analysis as described below. Exclusion criteria were applied to ensure data quality and participant engagement. Specifically, participants were excluded if they demonstrated inattentiveness (defined as more than 8 mistakes on comprehension quizzes during the instruction phase), displayed less than 90% accuracy in selecting the correct vehicle corresponding to its pre-learned destination (mean error rate = 3%, range [0–10%]; indicating a lack of task comprehension), or chose not to purchase any tickets in 90% or more of trials across all experimental conditions (suggesting a lack of engagement with the task). These criteria led to the exclusion of 22 participants (8.3% exclusion rate) from the initial study and 23 participants (8.9% exclusion rate) from the replication study. Participants gave written informed consent before taking part in the study, which was approved by the university’s ethics review board (approval number: 2022-06213). Participants were paid at a rate of 9 euros per hour.

Experimental task

Participants were informed about the location of a treasure (150 coins, worth 15¢ of bonus monetary compensation) and could exercise control by boarding the train to reach the house or the plane to reach the mountain (see main text and Figure 2). Forgoing or failing to board resulted in walking to the nearest location, which happened to be where the treasure was located 20% of the time.

The first ticket (cost = 40 coins) allowed participants to select their desired vehicle, but it only stopped for them at the platform some percentage of the time, corresponding to the inelastic controllability of the planet. Participants could purchase up to 2 additional tickets (cost = 20 coins each) to attempt boarding the moving vehicle after it had left the platform. This improved the probability of boarding in correspondence with the elastic controllability of the planet.

When participants purchased a second or third ticket, the chosen vehicle appeared moving from left to right across the screen, and participants attempted to board it by pressing the spacebar when it reached the center of the screen. The precision of each boarding attempt was quantified as the absolute distance of the vehicle from the screen’s center at the time of the press. Unless elastic control was below 15%, boarding attempts with precision in the top 15th percentile relative to the participant’s prior performance automatically succeeded, and unless elastic control was above 85%, those in the bottom 15th percentile automatically failed. For the remaining attempts, the outcome was probabilistically determined such that the overall probability of successfully boarding matched the elasticity of control on that planet. To verify that participants’ pressing ability did not bias their preference for purchasing extra tickets, we ran a mixed probit regression of the number of extra tickets purchased on participants’ average press precision. We found no significant effect (p=0.45). When participants purchased multiple tickets, they made all boarding attempts in sequence without intermediate feedback, only learning whether they successfully boarded upon reaching their final destination. This served two purposes. First, to ensure that participants would consistently need to invest not only more money but also more effort and time in planets with high elastic controllability. Second, to ensure that results could potentially generalize to the many real-world situations where the amount of invested effort has to be determined prior to seeing any outcome (e.g. preparing for an exam or a job interview).

At the end of each trip, participants were shown where they arrived, allowing them to infer whether they successfully boarded their vehicle. Since this feedback is only interpretable if participants knew each vehicle’s destination, we only included participants in subsequent analyses if they chose the vehicle corresponding to the destination of the treasure with at least 90% accuracy (mean 97%±2%, see first exclusion criteria). The average trial duration was approximately 11 s (SE = 0.05), with each additional ticket extending this duration by approximately 0.5 s (SE = 0.04), increasing the time investment required from participants.

To allow sufficient learning of each planet’s elasticity and controllability, participants took 30 consecutive trips on each planet. This trip count was determined based on pilot data (N=19) by analyzing when participants’ strategies stabilized. Specifically, we examined the standard deviation in ticket choices over the final 5 trips and found stabilization after around 15 trips (STD = 0.33 compared to 0.63 in the first 15 trips). Based on this, we provided 15 initial trips per planet for learning and analyzed ticket choices starting from trip 16 onward. This approach followed our pre-registered plan.

To homogenize the learning experience across participants, we gave participants 3 free tickets for the first five visits to every planet. However, only four of those trips were informative, since on one of every five trips (randomly placed), the treasure was located in the nearby location, making boarding inconsequential for reaching it.

Points accumulated across all planets throughout the session, with participants explicitly motivated to maximize their total points as this directly determined their monetary bonus payment. To ensure that accumulated gains did not lead participants to adopt a simple heuristic strategy of always purchasing 3 tickets, we conducted a mixed probit regression examining whether the number of accumulated coins influenced participants’ decisions to purchase extra tickets. We did not find such an effect (βcoins accumulated=0.01p=0.87)\begin{document}$\left (\beta _{coins \ accumulated}=0.01 \, {\rm p}=0.87\right)$\end{document}, ruling out the potential strategy shift.

Planet types

To study elasticity learning across all possible degrees of controllability and elasticity, 66 unique planet conditions were generated by systematically varying inelastic controllability (the probability of the chosen vehicle stopping at the platform if purchasing a single ticket) and elasticity (the added probability of boarding from purchasing 2 extra tickets) from 0% to 100% in 10% increments. The treasure value (150 coins) and ticket costs (40 coins for the first ticket, 20 coins for extra tickets) were chosen so that the optimal strategy, as determined by expected value calculations (Equation 11), was to purchase 0 tickets on 22 planets (low-controllability condition), 1 ticket on a different set of 22 planets (high inelastic controllability condition), and 3 tickets on the remaining 22 planets (high elastic controllability condition). Participants were randomly assigned one planet from each condition, while ensuring they could earn roughly the same total number of coins if they made optimal choices (initial study = 45 ± 0.3; replication study 46 ± 0.3). To address potential confounds between controllability and predictability (Ligneul, 2021), we designed the experiment such that high-controllability planets (where purchasing 1 or 3 tickets was optimal) were not inherently more predictable than low-controllability planets. We quantified predictability as the entropy of the probability distribution determining whether the participant will or will not arrive at the rewarded location. For 60% of participants, purchasing tickets on high-controllability planets decreased entropy (i.e. increased predictability) compared to low-controllability planets, whereas for the other 40% it increased entropy (i.e. decreased predictability). To increase sensitivity to individual differences, all participants first encountered a planet where purchasing any number of tickets (0, 1, 2, or 3) yielded the same expected value (EV = 30 coins).

Initial training

Prior to engaging in the task, participants completed 90 practice trials. These practice trials were divided equally across planets with high inelastic controllability, high elastic controllability, and low controllability. To reinforce participants’ understanding of how elasticity and controllability were manifested in each planet, they were informed of the planet type they had visited after every 15 trips. Specifically, for high inelastic controllability planets, the message read: ‘Your ride actually would stop for you with 1 ticket! So purchasing extra tickets, since they do cost money, is a WASTE.’ For low-controllability planets: ‘Doesn't seem like the vehicle stops for you nor does purchasing extra tickets help.’ Lastly, for high elastic controllability planets: ‘Hopefully by now it’s clear that only by purchasing 3 tickets (LOADING AREA) are you consistently successful in catching your ride.’

Power analysis

The sample sizes for both the initial and the replication studies were pre-registered before data collection commenced. For the initial study, we derived the sample size of 264 participants using a power analysis aiming to estimate with high accuracy (credible interval width <0.1) the likelihood that participants will opt in for any combination of elastic and inelastic control (66 total combinations). For this purpose, we used Kruschke, 2014, procedure for Bayesian power analysis (Kruschke, 2014). Based on pilot data (N=19), we fitted a Bayesian beta binomial model to the proportion of opt-ins in the planet with no optimal strategy (and therefore the highest variability in behavior would be expected), and found that 12 participants were required for the credible interval of the binomial proportion parameter to be lower than 0.1. Since each participant completes three combinations of elastic and inelastic control, we multiplied the required sample size by the total number of planets in each condition (22), which results in an estimate of n=264.

To examine whether this sample size is sufficient to detect significant effects of elastic and inelastic controllability on opting in (Figure 3A and C), and the purchasing of extra tickets (Figure 3B and C), we used a bootstrap procedure whereby we sampled 264 participants from the pilot data and ran the regression analyses on them. We repeated this procedure for 50 iterations, each time recording βelastic,βinelastic\begin{document}$\beta _{elastic},\beta _{inelastic}$\end{document}, and their p-values. For analysis 1, we found that both βelastic∧βinelastic\begin{document}$\beta _{elastic}\wedge \beta _{inelastic}$\end{document} were significantly above 0 in all iterations, and for analysis 2, βelastic\begin{document}$\beta _{elastic}$\end{document} was significantly above 0 in all iterations, thereby giving us >98% power to detect all of our effects of interest. Confidence intervals were derived from a binomial test in which a positive significant coefficient counted as a success.

For the replication study, we derived the sample size of 250 participants using a power analysis aiming for 95% power to detect a significant (p<0.05) canonical correlation between the model-derived parameters and questionnaire scores (Figure 6B). For this purpose, we sampled with replacement from the initial dataset (n=264), which had showed a significant canonical correlation (p=0.01; Figure 6B), and calculated the p-value of a CCA in the subsample. We repeated this procedure for 100 iterations, each time recording the calculated p-value. To ensure our sample size was sufficient to detect significant effects in the regression models predicting opt-in and extra ticket purchases from the composite psychopathology score with over 95% power (Figure 6C), we conducted another bootstrap analysis. We sampled 250 participants with replacement each time calculating the composite score and ran the regression analyses on that score, repeating this procedure 100 times. We found that βcomposite\begin{document}$\beta _{composite}$\end{document} was significant (p<0.05) in 95% of iterations (95% power).

Regression analyses

Mixed model regression analyses were performed using the ‘ordinal’ package which fits cumulative mixed models via Laplace approximations (Christensen, 2019). The model predicts the likelihood of purchasing tickets (logistic model) and how many extra tickets are purchased (probit model) on the last 15 trips on each planet. Predictors included fixed and random effects for elastic and inelastic controllability and fixed and random intercepts per participant and planet number, with the latter included to account for potential learning or fatigue effects. Statistical significance was assessed using the Wald Z test (Agresti, 2002) with normality assessed using the Shapiro-Wilk test (Shapiro and Wilk, 1965).

Computational modeling

To assess whether participants inferred elasticity or merely learned the control afforded by each course of action separately, we fit two competing reinforcement-learning models (‘controllability’ and ‘elastic controllability’). Both models use beta distributions defined by parameters (a, b), to form controllability beliefs for each ticket quantity n (n ∈ {1, 2, 3}), but only the elastic controllability model leverages the dependencies that exist between different levels of resource investment. Below, we expand on the computations underlying both models.

Controllability model

The controllability model accumulates the number of times that each ticket quantity n led to successful or unsuccessful boarding:(1)an←an+Obn←bn+(1−O)\begin{document}$$\displaystyle \begin{array}{ll}\rm a_{n}\leftarrow a_{n}+O\\ \rm b_{n}\leftarrow b_{n}+\left (1- O\right)\end{array}$$\end{document}

where O=1 if boarding was successful and O=0 if not. The probability of boarding with 1, 2, or 3 tickets on planet s is thus simply the expected value of that particular beta distribution:(2)p(boarding|n,s)=anan+bn.\begin{document}$$\displaystyle \rm p\left (boarding | n,s\right)=\frac{a_{n}}{a_{n}+b_{n}}.$$\end{document}

Here, and in all subsequent models, learning only takes place when the treasure is not located on the nearby planet, which makes it possible to identify boarding success.

Elastic controllability model

The elastic controllability model explains ticket choices based on latent beliefs about the controllability and elasticity of each planet (see Figure 4). These beliefs are represented by three beta distributions, each defined by two parameters (a,b)\begin{document}$\left (a,b\right)$\end{document}. The expected value of one beta distribution (defined by acontrol,bcontrol\begin{document}$a_{control},b_{control}$\end{document}) represents the belief that boarding is possible (controllability) with any number of tickets, whereas the expected value of the other two beta distributions represents the belief that successful boarding is added by purchasing at least one (aelastic≥1,belastic2\begin{document}$a_{elastic\geq 1},b_{elastic2}$\end{document}) or specifically two (aelastic2,belastic2\begin{document}$a_{elastic2},b_{elastic2}$\end{document}) extra tickets (elasticity).

Thus, the parameter acontrol\begin{document}$a_{control}$\end{document} accumulates the number of successful boarding attempts with any number of tickets, whereas bcontrol\begin{document}$b_{control}$\end{document} accumulates the number of failed boarding attempts despite purchasing the maximum number of tickets (3 tickets):(3)acontrol←acontrol+1 if win with 1,2,or 3 ticketsbcontrol←bcontrol+1 if lose with 3 tickets\begin{document}$$\displaystyle \begin{array}{ll}\rm a_{control}\leftarrow a_{control}+1\ if \ win\ with \ 1,2, or\ 3\ tickets\\ \rm b_{control}\leftarrow b_{control}+1\ if \ lose \ with \ 3 \ tickets\end{array}$$\end{document}

A failure to board with fewer tickets doesn’t reduce the maximum controllability estimate but instead suggests that more tickets or the maximum number of tickets may be needed to obtain control:(4)aelastic≥1←aelastic≥1+1 if lose with 1 or 2 ticketsaelastic2←aelastic2+1 if lose with 2 tickets\begin{document}$$\displaystyle \begin{array}{ll}\rm a_{elastic\geq 1}\leftarrow a_{elastic\geq 1}+1\ if \ lose \ with \ 1 \ or \ 2 \ tickets\\ \rm a_{elastic2}\leftarrow a_{elastic2}+1\ if \ lose \ with \ 2 \ tickets\end{array}$$\end{document}

Conversely, successfully boarding with fewer tickets is evidence that obtaining controllability does not require maximal or any extra tickets:(5)belastic≥1←belastic≥1+if win with 1 ticketbelastic2←belastic2+1 if win with 2 tickets\begin{document}$$\displaystyle \begin{array}{ll}\rm b_{elastic\geq 1}\leftarrow b_{elastic\geq 1}+if \ win \ with \ 1 \ ticket\\ \rm b_{elastic2}\leftarrow b_{elastic2}+1 \ if \ win \ with \ 2 \ tickets\end{array}$$\end{document}

To account for our finding that failure with 3 tickets made participants favor 3, over 1 and 2, tickets, we introduced a modified elastic controllability* model, wherein purchasing extra tickets is also favored upon receiving evidence of low controllability (loss with 3 tickets). This effect was modulated by a free parameter κκ which reflects a tendency to prioritize resolving uncertainty about whether control is at all possible by investing maximum resources:(6)amore←aelastic1+κ if lose with 3 ticketsaelastic2←aelastic2+κ if lose with 3 tickets\begin{document}$$\displaystyle \begin{array}{ll}\rm a_{more}\leftarrow a_{elastic1}+\kappa \ if \ lose \ with \ 3 \ tickets\\ \rm a_{elastic2}\leftarrow a_{elastic2}+\kappa\ if \ lose \ with \ 3 \ tickets\end{array}$$\end{document}

The estimated controllability and elasticity, as characterized by the expected value of the three beta distributions (Ctotal control,Cmore,Cfull\begin{document}$C_{\rm total \ \rm control},C_{\rm more},C_{\rm full}$\end{document}), is used to derive the probability of boarding the selected vehicle with 1, 2, or 3 tickets. Thus, the estimated probability of boarding with 1 ticket is an estimate of inelastic control, i.e., the percentage of the total control Ctotal control\begin{document}$C_{\rm total \ \rm control}$\end{document} that does not require investing more resources:(7)P(boarding|n=1)=Ctotal control×(1−Cmore)\begin{document}$$\displaystyle \rm P\left (boarding|n=1\right)=C_{total \ control}\times \left (1- C_{more}\right)$$\end{document}

For 2 tickets, the added probability of boarding is an estimate of what percentage of total control is elastic (Cmore\begin{document}$\rm C_{more}$\end{document}) but does not require investing maximal resources (1−Cfull)\begin{document}$\rm \left (1- C_{full}\right)$\end{document}:(8)P(boarding|n=2)=Ps(boarding|n=1)+Ctotal control×Cmore×(1−Cfull)\begin{document}$$\displaystyle \rm P\left (boarding|n=2\right)=P_{s}\left (boarding|n=1\right)+C_{total\ control}\times C_{more}\times \left (1- C_{full}\right)$$\end{document}

Finally, since 3 tickets is the maximum resource investment, the estimated probability of boarding with 3 tickets is equivalent to an estimate of total attainable control.(9)P(boarding|n=3,s)=Ctotal control\begin{document}$$\displaystyle \rm P\left (boarding|n=3,s\right)=C_{total \ control}$$\end{document}

Models’ resource investment

Because participants win 20% of the time even when they fail to board their selected ride, we calculate the probability of arriving at the treasure with n tickets as:(10)P(win|n)=P(boarding|n)+0.2×(1−P(boarding|n))\begin{document}$$\displaystyle \rm P\left (win| n\right)=P\left (boarding| n\right)+0.2\times \left (1- P\left (boarding| n\right)\right)$$\end{document}

Then, taking the possible reward (R=150\rm R=150) and ticket costs (C={40,20,20}\begin{document}$\rm C=\left \{40,20,20\right \}$\end{document}) into account, the expected value for purchasing n tickets (n={1,2,3})\begin{document}$\rm \left (n=\left \{1,2,3\right \}\right)$\end{document} is:(11)V(n)=(R−∑i=1nCi)×P(win|n)−∑i=1nCi×(1−P(win|n))\begin{document}$$\displaystyle \rm V\left (n\right)=\left (R- \sum _{i=1}^{n}C_{i}\right)\times P\left (win|n\right)- \sum _{i=1}^{n}C_{i}\times \left (1- P\left (win|n\right)\right)$$\end{document}

One exception to this rule is the expected value of opting out, V(0)\begin{document}$\rm V\left (0\right)$\end{document}, which is similar across all planets, and equals the potential reward (150) times the probability that walking will lead to the reward (0.2).

The probability that a participant will purchase 0, 1, 2, or 3 tickets is calculated using the SoftMax function such that:(12)p(n)∝β×V(n)+αn+ρ×I(nt−1==n)\begin{document}$$\displaystyle p\rm\left (n\right)\propto \beta \times V\left (n\right)+\alpha _{n}+\rho \times I\left (n_{t- 1}==n\right)$$\end{document}

where ββ is an inverse temperature parameter, α1−3\begin{document}$\alpha _{1- 3}$\end{document} are parameters that represent participants’ fixed tendencies to purchase 1, 2, or 3 tickets, respectively, and ρρ is a perseveration parameter that represents participant tendency to purchase the same number of tickets as in the last trial (nt−1\begin{document}$\rm n_{t- 1}$\end{document}). A0\begin{document}$\rm A _{0}$\end{document} is set to 0 to maintain parameter identifiability.

We compared the aforementioned models to a null model wherein participants have distinct preferences among different number of tickets (α1−3\begin{document}$\alpha _{1- 3}$\end{document}) and perseveration (ρρ ) but no latent controllability estimates (β=0∈ Equation12\begin{document}$\beta =0\in\ {\rm Equation \, 12}$\end{document}). We also evaluated variants of both models that replaced the SoftMax-based exploration (governed by inverse temperature β) with a decaying epsilon-greedy approach. This epsilon-greedy variant, which begins with a fixed exploration rate that decreases with the number of trials (Kalidindi and Bowman, 2007), performed significantly worse at explaining participants’ choices compared to the SoftMax-based models.

Prior controllability and elasticity beliefs

To capture prior biases that planets are controllable and elastic, we introduced parameters γcontrollability\begin{document}$\gamma _{\rm controllability}$\end{document} and γelasticity\begin{document}$\gamma _{\rm elasticity}$\end{document}, each computed by multiplying the direction (λ – 0.5) and strength (ϵ) of individuals’ prior belief. λcontrollabilityandλelasticity\begin{document}$\lambda _{\rm controllability}\,{\rm and}\, \lambda _{\rm elasticity}$\end{document} range between 0 and 1, with values above 0.5 indicating a bias toward high controllability or elasticity, and values below 0.5 indicating a bias toward low controllability or elasticity. ϵcontrollability\begin{document}$\epsilon _{\rm controllability}$\end{document} and ϵelasticity\begin{document}$\epsilon _{\rm elasticity}$\end{document} are positively valued parameters capturing confidence in the bias. Parameter recovery analyses confirmed both good recoverability (see Appendix 1—table 2) and low confusion between bias direction and strength (ϵcontrollability\begin{document}$\epsilon _{\rm controllability}$\end{document}→λcontrollability=−0.07,\begin{document}$\lambda _{\rm controllability}=- 0.07,$\end{document}
λcontrollability\begin{document}$\lambda _{\rm controllability}$\end{document}→ϵcontrollability=−0.16,ϵelasticity\begin{document}$\epsilon _{\rm controllability}=- 0.16,\epsilon _{\rm elasticity}$\end{document}→λelasticity=0.15,\begin{document}$\lambda _{\rm elasticity}=0.15,$\end{document}
λelasticity\begin{document}$\lambda _{\rm elasticity}$\end{document}→ϵelasticity=0.04\begin{document}$\epsilon _{\rm elasticity}=0.04$\end{document}), ensuring that observed biases and their relation to psychopathology do not merely reflect slower learning (Appendix 1—figure 4), which can result from changes in bias strength but not direction.

For each new planet participants encountered, these parameters were used to initialize the beta distributions representing participants’ beliefs:(13)acontrollability=2×ϵcontrollability×λcontrollabilitybcontrollability=ϵcontrollability×(1−λcontrollability)amore,full=ϵelasticity×λelasticitybmore,full,=ϵelasticity×(1−λelasticity)\begin{document}$$\displaystyle \begin{array}{ll}\rm a_{controllability}=2\times \epsilon _{controllability}\times \lambda _{controllability}\\ \rm b_{controllability}=\epsilon _{controllability}\times \left (1- \lambda _{controllability}\right)\\ \rm a_{more,full}=\epsilon _{elasticity}\times \lambda _{elasticity}\\ \rm b_{more,full,}=\epsilon _{elasticity}\times \left (1- \lambda _{elasticity}\right)\end{array}$$\end{document}

acontrollability\begin{document}$a_{\rm controllability}$\end{document} is multiplied by 2 so that in the absence of a bias, it would have equal preference for purchasing 0–3 tickets (this requires that Ccontrollability=23\begin{document}$\rm C_{controllability}=\frac{2}{3}$\end{document}, Cmore,full=12\begin{document}$\rm C_{more,full}=\frac{1}{2}$\end{document}).

For consistency, in the ‘controllability model’, the controllability estimates for each ticket quantity are initialized for each ticket quantity n, where n={1,2,3}, as:(14)an=ϵn×λnbn=ϵn×(1−λn)\begin{document}$$\displaystyle \begin{array}{ll}\rm a_{n}=\epsilon _{n}\times \lambda _{n}\\ \rm b_{n}=\epsilon _{n}\times \left (1- \lambda _{n}\right)\end{array}$$\end{document}

Here, to ensure no preference between different ticket quantities in the absence of a bias, a1\begin{document}$a_{1}$\end{document} is multiplied by 2 and a2\begin{document}$a_{2}$\end{document} is multiplied by 32\begin{document}$\frac{3}{2}$\end{document}.

Testing alternative models

To further validate our elastic controllability model, we tested it against several theoretically motivated alternatives that could potentially explain participants’ behavior.

To ascertain that participants were truly learning latent estimates of controllability rather than simpler associations, we conducted two complementary analyses.

First, we implemented a simple Q-learning model that directly maps ticket quantities to expected values based on reward prediction errors, without representing latent controllability. This associative model performed substantially worse than even our simple controllability model (log Bayes factor ≥1854 on the combined datasets). Second, we fitted a variant of the elastic controllability model that compared learning from control-related versus chance outcomes via separate parameters (instead of assuming no learning from chance outcomes). Chance outcomes were observed by participants in the 20% of trials where reward and control were decoupled, in the sense that participants reached the treasure regardless of whether they boarded their vehicle of choice. Results showed that participants learned considerably more from control-related, as compared to chance, outcomes (mean learning ratio = 1.90, CI = [1.83, 1.97]). Together, these analyses show that participants were forming latent controllability estimates rather than direct action-outcome associations.

Having established that participants indeed learn latent controllability estimates, we next examined our model’s interpretation of the κ parameter. Our model accounts for the observation that failures with 3 tickets made participants more likely to purchase 3 tickets when they opted in. To test whether this behavior resulted from participants not accepting that the planet is uncontrollable, we implemented a variant of the model where κ not only increases the elasticity estimate but also reduces the controllability update (using βcontrol\begin{document}$\beta _{\rm control}$\end{document}+(1 – κκ ) instead of βcontrol\begin{document}$\beta _{control}$\end{document}+1) after failures with 3 tickets. However, implementing this coupling diminished the model’s fit to the data (log Bayes factor ≥48), as compared to allowing both effects to occur independently, indicating that the increase in 3 ticket purchases upon failing with 3 tickets did not result from participants not accepting that controllability is, in fact, low. Thus, we maintained our original interpretation that failure with 3 tickets increases uncertainty about whether control is possible at all, leading participants who continue to opt in to invest maximum resources to resolve this uncertainty.

Having validated our interpretation of κ, we next examined whether participant behavior would be better characterized as a continuous function approximation rather than the discrete inferences in our model. To test this, we implemented a Bayesian model where participants continuously estimate both controllability and its elasticity as a mixture of three archetypal functions mapping ticket quantities to success probabilities. The flat function provides no control regardless of how many tickets are purchased (corresponding to low controllability). The step function provides full control as long as at least 1 ticket is purchased (inelastic controllability). The linear function linearly increases control with the number of extra tickets (i.e. 0%, 50%, and 100% control for 1, 2, and 3 tickets, respectively; elastic controllability). The model computes the likelihood that each of the functions produced each new observation, and accordingly updates its beliefs. Using these beliefs, the model estimates the probability of success for purchasing each number of tickets, allowing participants to weigh expected control against increasing ticket costs. Despite its theoretical advantages for generalization to different ticket quantities, this continuous function approximation model performed significantly worse than the elastic controllability model (log Bayes factor >4100 on combined datasets), suggesting that participants did not assume that control increases linearly with resource investment.

Model fitting

Reinforcement-learning models were fitted to all choices made by participants via an expectation maximization approach used in previous work (Eldar et al., 2018; Eldar et al., 2020; Solomyak et al., 2022). We generated random parameter settings drawn from predefined group-level distributions and calculated the likelihood of observing the participants’ choices given each parameter setting. We then approximated the posterior estimates of the group-level prior distributions for each parameter by resampling the parameter values, weighted by their respective likelihoods, and refitted the data based on the updated priors. This iterative process of resampling and refitting continued until no further improvement to model fit. To determine the best-fitting parameters for each individual participant, we computed a weighted average of the final batch of parameter settings, where each setting was weighted by the likelihood it assigned to the individual participant’s choices.

Model parameter ββ was initialized by sampling from a gamma distribution (k=1, θ=1), λλ was initialized by sampling from a beta distribution (α=1 and β=1), ϵε was initialized by sampling from a lognormal distribution (μ=0, σ=1), and all other parameters (α1−3,ρ,κ\begin{document}$\alpha _{1- 3},\rho ,\kappa$\end{document}) were initialized by sampling from a normal distribution (μ=0, σ=1).

Validation of model fitting procedure

To validate the model fitting procedure, we simulated data using each model and using the model comparison procedure to recover the correct model (Appendix 1—table 1). Furthermore, we validated our parameter fits by simulating data using the best-fitting parameters for each parameter and then recovering those parameters. The correlations for the parameters of interest were all equal to or greater than r=0.74 and at least 0.63 for all other parameters (see Appendix 1—table 2).

Model comparison

To compare between models, in terms of how well each model accounted for participants’ choices, we employed the integrated Bayesian information criterion (iBIC) (Eldar et al., 2016; Huys et al., 2012). First, we estimated the evidence for each model (L) by calculating the mean likelihood of the model given 200,000 random parameter settings sampled from the fitted group-level prior distributions. Subsequently, we computed the iBIC by penalizing the model evidence to account for model complexity, following this formula: iBIC = 2 ln L+k ln n, where k represents the number of fitted parameters, and n is the number of subject choices used to compute the likelihood. Lower iBIC values indicate a more parsimonious and better-fitting model.

Model simulations

To examine the predictions of the ‘controllability’ and ‘elastic controllability’ models, we simulated choices using the best-fitting parameter settings obtained from participants’ actual choices. For generality, planets were randomized in the simulation as they were in the actual experiment, such that a simulated participant did not visit precisely the same planets as the actual participant. Furthermore, to avoid discrepancies between models, each planet was repeated the same number of times for both models. 2000 simulations were performed with each model.

Individual differences

We examined individual biases in elasticity inference using participants’ best-fitting parameters for beliefs about controllability (γcontrollability)\begin{document}$ (\gamma _{\rm controllability})$\end{document} and elasticity (γelasticity\begin{document}$\gamma _{\rm elasticity}$\end{document}). In addition to these focal parameters, we also examined four other parameters that directly influence opt-in decisions and extra ticket purchases: an inverse temperature/noise parameter (β) and three baseline preference parameters (α1, α2, α3).

We then regressed participants’ actual opt-in (logistic regression) and extra ticket purchases (probit regression) in each of the three controllability conditions on participants’ parameters.

Regressions were performed in the lme4 package in R using RStudio (R Development Core Team, 2022; RStudio Team, 2022). Statistical significance was assessed using the Wald Z test (Agresti, 2002) with normality assessed using the Shapiro-Wilk test (Shapiro and Wilk, 1965).

Self-report measures

To assess trait-level agency beliefs and related psychopathologies, we administered the Sense of Agency Scale (Tapal et al., 2017). Additionally, we measured dysfunctional attitudes toward problem-solving via the Negative Problem Orientation Questionnaire (NPOQ) (Robichaud and Dugas, 2005a; Robichaud and Dugas, 2005b) and temperamental differences (five domains: hyperthymic, dysthymic, cyclothymic, irritable, and anxious) via the Temperament Evaluation Questionnaire (TEMPS-A) (Akiskal and Akiskal, 2005; Akiskal et al., 2005).

Additionally, we incorporated a selection of questionnaires used by Gillan et al., 2016, which assess three factors – anxious-depression, compulsive behavior and intrusive thought, and social withdrawal – linked to goal-directed control deficits. These include the Apathy Evaluation Scale (AES) (Marin et al., 1991), Eating Attitudes Test (EAT) (Garner et al., 1982), Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test (AUDIT) (Saunders et al., 1993), Barratt Impulsiveness Scale (BIS) (Heimberg et al., 1999), Liebowitz Social Anxiety Scale (LSAS) (Zung, 1965), Self-Rating Depression Scale (SDS) (Spielberger, 1983), Trait Subscale of the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory for Adults (STAI) (Foa et al., 2002; Spielberger, 1983), and the revised Obsessive-Compulsive Inventory (OCI-R) (Wise and Dolan, 2020).

We utilized abbreviated versions of these questionnaires following the methodology of Wise and Dolan, 2020 (Thomas and Clifford, 2017), who refined the questionnaires using a classifier to retain the items most contributory to variance in the three factors without significant information loss.

As pre-registered, we aggregated the scores of the selected items from each questionnaire independently for inclusion in our CCA. Questionnaires were scored following the corresponding scoring guide, but in such a way that larger scores always indicate greater psychopathology. Based on best practice recommendations (Barends and de Vries, 2019; Alfons et al., 2016), participants were screened for inattentive responding with infrequency items (‘I competed in the 1917 Summer Olympic Games’), which resulted in the removal of 11 participants (initial: 6, replication: 5).

Directly using the scores from questionnaires of varying lengths in the CCA can give undue influence to short questionnaires, whose scores are likely more noisy. To mitigate this problem, we adjusted the standard deviation of each questionnaire’s score proportionally to the square root of its number of items before conducting the CCA (in accordance with the formula for standard error). After performing the CCA on these weighted scores and normalized model parameters, the resulting canonical loadings were transformed back to their original standardized scale, ensuring that the reported loadings accurately reflected the original, unweighted scale of the questionnaire scores.

Canonical correlation analysis

CCA was implemented using the robust CCA method based on projection pursuit (‘ccAPP’ package) (Kalidindi and Bowman, 2007). We searched for the single canonical dimension that maximizes the Spearman correlation between the model parameters and psychopathology scores. Significance testing was conducted using a two-tailed permutation test with 1000 iterations. In each iteration, the model parameters were shuffled relative to the psychopathology scores, and the canonical correlation was recalculated. The observed canonical correlation was then compared to this null distribution to obtain a p-value. To evaluate the contribution of the elasticity prior parameter (γelasticity\begin{document}$\gamma _{elasticity}$\end{document}) to the parameter-psychopathology correlation, we performed an additional permutation test. In this test, only the elasticity bias estimates (γelasticity\begin{document}$\gamma _{elasticity}$\end{document}) were shuffled, while all other model parameters and self-report scores remained constant.

To assess how the identified psychopathological profile manifests in raw task measures, we calculated a composite psychopathology score for each participant. This score was derived by multiplying individual participant scores by CCA-derived loadings, representing their position on the psychopathology spectrum. We then used this composite score as a predictor (βcomposite\begin{document}$\beta _{\rm composite}$\end{document}) in a linear regression model to forecast the difference in average opt-in and extra ticket behavior between conditions where controllability was high and inelastic versus high and elastic.

References

Agresti A 2002 Categorical Data Analysis John Wiley & Sons10.1002/0471249688

Akiskal KK Akiskal HS 2005 The theoretical underpinnings of affective temperaments: implications for evolutionary foundations of bipolar disorder and human nature Journal of Affective Disorders 85 231 239 10.1016/j.jad.2004.08.002 15780693

Akiskal HS Mendlowicz MV Jean-Louis G Rapaport MH Kelsoe JR Gillin JC Smith TL 2005 TEMPS-A: validation of a short version of a self-rated instrument designed to measure variations in temperament Journal of Affective Disorders 85 45 52 10.1016/j.jad.2003.10.012 15780675

Alfons A Croux C Filzmoser P 2016 Robust maximum association between data sets: The R Package ccaPP Austrian Journal of Statistics 45 71 79 10.17713/ajs.v45i1.90

Barends AJ de Vries RE 2019 Noncompliant responding: Comparing exclusion criteria in MTurk personality research to improve data quality Personality and Individual Differences 143 84 89 10.1016/j.paid.2019.02.015

Beyer F Sidarus N Fleming S Haggard P 2018 Losing control in social situations: how the presence of others affects neural processes related to sense of agency eNeuro 5 ENEURO.0336-17.201810.1523/ENEURO.0336-17.2018 29527568 PMC5844060

Bi R Dong W Zheng Z Li S Zhang D 2022 Altered motivation of effortful decision-making for self and others in subthreshold depression Depression and Anxiety 39 633 645 10.1002/da.23267 35657301 PMC9543190

Cao S-Q Tang C-C Wu H-Y Liu X 2022 Value analysis determines when and how to strive Advances in Psychological Science 30 877 887 10.3724/SP.J.1042.2022.00877

Chambon V Théro H Vidal M Vandendriessche H Haggard P Palminteri S 2020 Information about action outcomes differentially affects learning from self-determined versus imposed choices Nature Human Behaviour 4 1067 1079 10.1038/s41562-020-0919-5 32747804

Christensen RHB 2019 Ordinal - regression models for ordinal dataR package 2019.12-10

Cohen RM Weingartner H Smallberg SA Pickar D Murphy DL 1982 Effort and cognition in depression Archives of General Psychiatry 39 593 597 10.1001/archpsyc.1982.04290050061012 7092490

Diener C Kuehner C Brusniak W Struve M Flor H 2009 Effects of stressor controllability on psychophysiological, cognitive and behavioural responses in patients with major depression and dysthymia Psychological Medicine 39 77 86 10.1017/S0033291708003437 18466665 PMC2830060

Dorfman HM Gershman SJ 2019 Controllability governs the balance between Pavlovian and instrumental action selection Nature Communications 10 582610.1038/s41467-019-13737-7 31862876 PMC6925275

Eldar E Hauser TU Dayan P Dolan RJ 2016 Striatal structure and function predict individual biases in learning to avoid pain PNAS 113 4812 4817 10.1073/pnas.1519829113 27071092 PMC4855606

Eldar E Roth C Dayan P Dolan RJ 2018 Decodability of reward learning signals predicts mood fluctuations Current Biology 28 1433 1439 10.1016/j.cub.2018.03.038 29706512 PMC5954908

Eldar E Lièvre G Dayan P Dolan RJ 2020 The roles of online and offline replay in planning eLife 9 e5691110.7554/eLife.56911 32553110 PMC7299337

Foa EB Huppert JD Leiberg S Langner R Kichic R Hajcak G Salkovskis PM 2002 The Obsessive-Compulsive Inventory: development and validation of a short version Psychological Assessment 14 485 496 12501574

Frömer R Lin H Dean Wolf CK Inzlicht M Shenhav A 2021 Expectations of reward and efficacy guide cognitive control allocation Nature Communications 12 103010.1038/s41467-021-21315-z 33589626 PMC7884731

Gallagher MW Naragon-Gainey K Brown TA 2014 Perceived control is a transdiagnostic predictor of cognitive-behavior therapy outcome for anxiety disorders Cognitive Therapy and Research 38 10 22 10.1007/s10608-013-9587-3 24563563 PMC3927880

Garner DM Olmsted MP Bohr Y Garfinkel PE 1982 The eating attitudes test: psychometric features and clinical correlates Psychological Medicine 12 871 878 10.1017/s0033291700049163 6961471

Gillan CM Morein-Zamir S Durieux AMS Fineberg NA Sahakian BJ Robbins TW 2014 Obsessive-compulsive disorder patients have a reduced sense of control on the illusion of control task Frontiers in Psychology 5 20410.3389/fpsyg.2014.00204 24659974 PMC3952480

Gillan CM Kosinski M Whelan R Phelps EA Daw ND 2016 Characterizing a psychiatric symptom dimension related to deficits in goal-directed control eLife 5 e1130510.7554/eLife.11305 26928075 PMC4786435

Grahek I Shenhav A Musslick S Krebs RM Koster EHW 2019 Motivation and cognitive control in depression Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews 102 371 381 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.04.011 31047891 PMC6642074

Grahek I Frömer R Prater Fahey M Shenhav A 2023 Learning when effort matters: neural dynamics underlying updating and adaptation to changes in performance efficacy Cerebral Cortex 33 2395 2411 10.1093/cercor/bhac215 35695774 PMC9977373

Heimberg RG Horner KJ Juster HR Safren SA Brown EJ Schneier FR Liebowitz MR 1999 Psychometric properties of the Liebowitz Social Anxiety Scale Psychological Medicine 29 199 212 10.1017/s0033291798007879 10077308

Huys QJM Dayan P 2009 A Bayesian formulation of behavioral control Cognition 113 314 328 10.1016/j.cognition.2009.01.008 19285311

Huys QJM Eshel N O’Nions E Sheridan L Dayan P Roiser JP 2012 Bonsai trees in your head: how the pavlovian system sculpts goal-directed choices by pruning decision trees PLOS Computational Biology 8 e100241010.1371/journal.pcbi.1002410 22412360 PMC3297555

Inzlicht M Shenhav A Olivola CY 2018 The effort paradox: effort is both costly and valued Trends in Cognitive Sciences 22 337 349 10.1016/j.tics.2018.01.007 29477776 PMC6172040

Kalidindi K Bowman H 2007 Using epsilon-greedy reinforcement learning methods to further understand ventromedial prefrontal patients’ deficits on the Iowa Gambling Task Neural Networks 20 676 689 10.1016/j.neunet.2007.04.026 17574813

Kruschke JK 2014 Doing Bayesian Data Analysis: A Tutorial with R, JAGS, and Stan 2nd edAcademic Press10.1016/B978-0-12-405888-0.00008-8

Li MY Callaway F Thompson WD Adams RP Griffiths TL 2023 Learning to learn functions Cognitive Science 47 e1326210.1111/cogs.13262 37051879

Ligneul R 2021 Prediction or causation? Towards a redefinition of task controllability Trends in Cognitive Sciences 25 431 433 10.1016/j.tics.2021.02.009 33712402

Ligneul R Mainen ZF Ly V Cools R 2022 Stress-sensitive inference of task controllability Nature Human Behaviour 6 812 822 10.1038/s41562-022-01306-w 35273354

Liljeholm M 2021 Agency and goal-directed choice Current Opinion in Behavioral Sciences 41 78 84 10.1016/j.cobeha.2021.04.004

Lin J 1991 Divergence measures based on the Shannon entropy IEEE Transactions on Information Theory 37 145 151 10.1109/18.61115

lsolomyak2026 Human_inference_of_elastic_controlswh:1:rev:8dfb321b613809ba431014725a868e792c49572dSoftware Heritagehttps://archive.softwareheritage.org/swh:1:dir:525200a0b9324b6df2cb04eb7e407638e324e51b;origin=https://github.com/lsolomyak/human_inference_of_elastic_control;visit=swh:1:snp:7d9983ddec8fb9844a4d244afa4c1990f4427b52;anchor=swh:1:rev:8dfb321b613809ba431014725a868e792c49572d

Marin RS Biedrzycki RC Firinciogullari S 1991 Reliability and validity of the Apathy Evaluation Scale Psychiatry Research 38 143 162 10.1016/0165-1781(91)90040-v 1754629

McLaren S Crowe SF 2003 The contribution of perceived control of stressful life events and thought suppression to the symptoms of obsessive-compulsive disorder in both non-clinical and clinical samples Journal of Anxiety Disorders 17 389 403 10.1016/s0887-6185(02)00224-4 12826088

Mistry P Liljeholm M 2016 Instrumental divergence and the value of control Scientific Reports 6 3629510.1038/srep36295 27811969 PMC5095609

Moscarello JM Hartley CA 2017 Agency and the calibration of motivated behavior Trends in Cognitive Sciences 21 725 735 10.1016/j.tics.2017.06.008 28693961

Moulding R Kyrios M 2006 Anxiety disorders and control related beliefs: the exemplar of Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD) Clinical Psychology Review 26 573 583 10.1016/j.cpr.2006.01.009 16647173

Msetfi RM Kornbrot DE Matute H Murphy RA 2015 The relationship between mood state and perceived control in contingency learning: effects of individualist and collectivist values Frontiers in Psychology 6 143010.3389/fpsyg.2015.01430 26483707 PMC4586436

Pindyck RS 2018 Microeconomics Pearson

Raab HA Foord C Ligneul R Hartley CA 2022 Developmental shifts in computations used to detect environmental controllability PLOS Computational Biology 18 e101012010.1371/journal.pcbi.1010120 35648788 PMC9191713

R Development Core Team2022 R: a language and environment for statistical computingVienna, AustriaR Foundation for Statistical Computinghttps://www.R-project.org

Reuven-Magril O Dar R Liberman N 2008 Illusion of control and behavioral control attempts in obsessive-compulsive disorder Journal of Abnormal Psychology 117 334 341 10.1037/0021-843X.117.2.334 18489209

Robichaud M Dugas MJ 2005a Negative problem orientation (Part I): psychometric properties of a new measure Behaviour Research and Therapy 43 391 401 10.1016/j.brat.2004.02.007 15680933

Robichaud M Dugas MJ 2005b Negative problem orientation (Part II): construct validity and specificity to worry Behaviour Research and Therapy 43 403 412 10.1016/j.brat.2004.02.008 15680934

RStudio Team2022 RStudio: integrated development for RPBC, Boston, MARStudiohttps://www.rstudio.com/

Salkovskis PM 1996 Cognitive-behavioral approaches to the understanding of obsessional problemsRapee RM Current Controversies in the Anxiety Disorders Guilford Press103 133

Saunders JB Aasland OG Babor TF de la Fuente JR Grant M 1993 Development of the Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test (AUDIT): WHO collaborative project on early detection of persons with harmful alcohol consumption--II Addiction 88 791 804 10.1111/j.1360-0443.1993.tb02093.x 8329970

Schunk DH 1982 Effects of effort attributional feedback on children’s perceived self-efficacy and achievement Journal of Educational Psychology 74 548 556 10.1037/0022-0663.74.4.548

Shapiro SS Wilk MB 1965 An analysis of variance test for normality (Complete Samples) Biometrika 52 59110.2307/2333709

Shenhav A Fahey MP Grahek I 2021 Decomposing the motivation to exert mental effort Current Directions in Psychological Science 30 307 314 10.1177/09637214211009510 34675454 PMC8528169

Solomyak L Sharp PB Eldar E 2022 Training diversity promotes absolute-value-guided choice PLOS Computational Biology 18 e101066410.1371/journal.pcbi.1010664 36322560 PMC9678339

Spielberger CD 1983 State-trait anxiety inventory for adults (STAI-AD) [database record]APA PsycTests

Sullivan-Toole H Richey JA Tricomi E 2016 Control and effort costs influence the motivational consequences of choice Frontiers in Psychology 8 1 12 10.3389/fpsyg.2017.00675 PMC5413552 28515705

Sutton RS 1984 Temporal Credit Assignment in Reinforcement Learning AmherstUniversity of Massachusetts

Tapal A Oren E Dar R Eitam B 2017 The sense of agency scale: a measure of consciously perceived control over one’s mind, body, and the immediate environment Frontiers in Psychology 8 155210.3389/fpsyg.2017.01552 PMC5600914 28955273

Thomas KA Clifford S 2017 Validity and mechanical turk: an assessment of exclusion methods and interactive experiments Computers in Human Behavior 77 184 197 10.1016/j.chb.2017.08.038

Wang KS Yang YY Delgado MR 2021 How perception of control shapes decision making Current Opinion in Behavioral Sciences 41 85 91 10.1016/j.cobeha.2021.04.003

Wise T Dolan RJ 2020 Associations between aversive learning processes and transdiagnostic psychiatric symptoms in a general population sample Nature Communications 11 417910.1038/s41467-020-17977-w 32826918 PMC7443146

Zorowitz S Momennejad I Daw ND 2020 Anxiety, avoidance, and sequential evaluation Computational Psychiatry 4 1 17 10.1162/cpsy_a_00026 34036174 PMC8143038

Zung WWK 1965 A self-rating depression scale Archives of General Psychiatry 12 63 70 10.1001/archpsyc.1965.01720310065008 14221692

Come citare questo studio

Solomyak L, Emanuel A, Eldar E. (2026). The resource elasticity of control.. eLife. DOI: 10.7554/elife.105507

Consulta la pubblicazione originale ↗